Showing posts with label seasons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label seasons. Show all posts

Sunday, February 22, 2026

Lent and the Gospel: A Debate on Faith, Works, and Salvation

 Lent and the Gospel: A Debate on Faith, Works, and Salvation



Lent has arrived once again, and as always, some anti-Catholic groups will claim that it is "pagan" and contradicts both the Gospel and Scripture. They argue that Lent transforms salvation—received by faith through grace alone—into a "works-based salvation." While I will address the "pagan" allegations in a separate discussion, this article will focus on why some groups believe Lent contradicts and even nullifies the Gospel.

As a Catholic, I observe Lent with devotion, striving to live according to its precepts and sacred Traditions. Beyond simply following Church teaching, I find that the practices of prayer, fasting, abstinence, and almsgiving—though valuable at any time of year—hold a unique spiritual significance in this season leading up to Pascua. They serve as a means of deepening my relationship with God, fostering holiness, and participating in the process of theosis or sanctification. However, not all Christian groups share this perspective. Some believe that Lent contradicts the Gospel and Scripture, turning faith into a "works-based salvation." In this discussion, we will explore why certain groups reject Lenten observances, why others embrace them, and how the Catholic Church understands and defends this sacred season.

The Gospel and the Debate Over Lent: Faith, Works, and Salvation

The Gospel, according to the Catholic Church, is the Good News of Jesus Christ—His life, death, and resurrection—through which He offers salvation and eternal life to all who believe in Him and follow His teachings. However, within Christianity, debates persist over how this Gospel should be understood and practiced, particularly regarding the observance of Lent.

Some Protestant and anti-Catholic groups reject Lent, arguing that its associated practices—fasting, prayer, and almsgiving—are works-based and contradict the biblical doctrine of salvation by grace alone through faith alone (Ephesians 2:8-9). From their perspective, salvation is a free gift from God that requires no additional actions beyond faith in Christ. They contend that engaging in Lenten observances implies that believers must perform acts of self-denial or good works to grow closer to God or to merit His grace, which they see as an affront to the sufficiency of Christ’s atonement.

Dr. John MacArthur, a well-known Protestant theologian, has criticized Lenten practices, stating: “The idea that we must somehow suffer or deprive ourselves to earn God’s favor or grow in holiness denies the sufficiency of Christ’s sacrifice. Our sanctification is the work of the Holy Spirit, not our own religious efforts.” Likewise, many evangelical groups argue that fasting and penance resemble Old Testament legalism rather than New Testament freedom in Christ.

Historically, the Protestant Reformation was largely a rejection of perceived Catholic legalism, and many reformers dismissed Lent as an unbiblical human tradition. Ulrich Zwingli, a Swiss reformer, opposed fasting regulations, writing that “God alone is to be served in spirit and in truth, not in outward observances.” Many evangelical churches today continue this tradition, emphasizing personal devotion over formalized liturgical practices.

The Ash Wednesday Debate

Additionally, some Protestant sects argue that the tradition of wearing ashes on one's forehead on Ash Wednesday contradicts Jesus' teaching in Matthew 6:16-18, where He instructs His followers not to look dismal when fasting but to wash their faces. They interpret this passage as a direct rejection of outward displays of piety, claiming that wearing ashes is an unbiblical, man-made tradition.

The Catholic Church, however, sees Ash Wednesday as a deeply biblical and meaningful tradition. The ashes serve as a sign of repentance, humility, and mortality, reminding believers of their dependence on God's mercy. The practice is rooted in Scripture, where ashes are frequently used as a symbol of penitence (e.g., Jonah 3:6, Daniel 9:3, Job 42:6). Rather than contradicting Jesus' words, the Catholic perspective holds that His teaching in Matthew 6 was a warning against hypocrisy, not against visible acts of faith performed with sincere heart.

The Catholic Perspective: Lent as a Gospel-Centered Practice

On the other hand, the Catholic Church—and even some Protestant denominations—defend Lent as a biblically rooted and spiritually enriching practice that aligns with, rather than contradicts, the Gospel. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states: “By the solemn forty days of Lent, the Church unites herself each year to the mystery of Jesus in the desert” (CCC 540).

Catholics do not view Lenten practices as a means of earning salvation but as a way to deepen one's relationship with Christ and conform more closely to His image. The Church teaches that works of penance, such as fasting, prayer, and almsgiving, are not done to earn God’s love but as a response to it. Pope Benedict XVI clarified this, stating: “Lent is not simply a time of self-denial; it is a time of deepening our faith in Christ and allowing His grace to transform us.”

Scripture itself supports fasting, prayer, and almsgiving as ways to grow in holiness. Jesus fasted for forty days in the wilderness (Matthew 4:1-11) and instructed His followers to fast (Matthew 6:16-18). The early Church continued these practices, as seen in Acts 13:2-3, where believers fasted and prayed before making important decisions.

Protestant Denominations That Observe Lent

Not all Protestants reject Lent. Many liturgical Protestant traditions, such as Anglicans, Lutherans, and Methodists, embrace Lent as a meaningful season of reflection. Martin Luther, though critical of Catholicism, did not reject fasting outright. In his Small Catechism, he wrote: “Fasting and bodily preparation are certainly fine outward training.” The Book of Common Prayer, central to Anglican worship, includes Lenten prayers and encourages fasting and self-examination. John Wesley, founder of Methodism, fasted regularly and saw spiritual value in the practice.

The Early Church on Lent and Spiritual Disciplines

The earliest Christians practiced fasting and penance as a response to God’s grace. The Church Father Tertullian (c. 155–220 AD) wrote, “Fasting possesses great power. If practiced with the right intention, it makes our prayers more effective and strengthens our relationship with God.” The Council of Nicaea (325 AD) formalized the forty-day Lenten season, reinforcing its widespread observance.

Conclusion: A Matter of Interpretation

Ultimately, the debate over Lent reflects broader theological differences regarding faith, works, and salvation. While some Protestant groups reject Lenten observances as a return to legalism, the Catholic Church and various Protestant traditions see them as a biblical and historical means of spiritual renewal. Far from undermining the Gospel, Lent, when properly understood, serves as a season of deeper conversion, echoing the words of James 2:17: “Faith by itself, if it is not accompanied by action, is dead.”

Thursday, December 4, 2025

Advent is Pagan!

 





Is Advent Pagan?

A Catholic Reflection and Defense

By Chris M. Forte

Every December, as the purple candles appear and the Church enters the quiet season of Advent, the same old accusations start to surface — that Advent is “pagan,” that it borrows from ancient solstice rituals, or that it’s just a repackaged version of sun-worship. Some even claim it’s “unbiblical” or “man-made tradition.”

Let’s be honest: these attacks don’t come from serious historical research. They come from ignorance, prejudice, and the same old anti-Catholic bigotry that’s been recycled for centuries. I’ve read the tracts, the blogs, the videos, and the “proofs.” None of them hold up to Scripture or history.

As a Catholic, I know Advent is not pagan — it’s profoundly Christian. Its meaning, symbols, and structure come straight from Scripture and the Church’s earliest understanding of Christ’s coming. The fact that some superficial parallels exist with pagan customs doesn’t make it pagan any more than pagans using fire made the discovery of fire demonic.

Let’s look at what the critics say — and then what the Church actually teaches.


1. The Accusations Against Advent

“It’s based on the pagan solstice festivals.”

Critics often point to the timing of Advent — late November through December — noting that it coincides with ancient midwinter festivals like Saturnalia or Yule. They claim the Church “Christianized” pagan sun celebrations to win converts. Some even say the increasing candlelight of the Advent wreath mimics pagan rituals celebrating the “return of the sun.”

This argument floats around the internet and in old anti-Catholic pamphlets. Writers like Alexander Hislop in The Two Babylons (1853) claimed most Catholic traditions, including Advent and Christmas, were just baptized Babylonian practices. Hislop wrote, “Papal worship is nothing else than the worship of Nimrod and his wife.” (Hislop, 1853).

Evangelical and fundamentalist circles have echoed this for decades. The accusation: that Advent — like Christmas — is just a pagan winter solstice party with Jesus’ name slapped on it.


“The Advent wreath is a pagan symbol.”

Another popular claim is that the Advent wreath — a circle of evergreens with four candles — comes from pre-Christian Germany, where pagans supposedly lit candles on evergreen wreaths to celebrate the return of the sun.

Yes, evergreen wreaths existed in ancient Europe. But the Christian Advent wreath as we know it was first developed in the 1800s by Johann Hinrich Wichern, a Lutheran pastor in Hamburg who used candles to teach children about waiting for Christmas. The custom spread quickly, and the Catholic Church embraced it as a devotional symbol, not a dogma.

So yes, the idea of a circle of greenery existed before Christianity — but so did bread, wine, and fire. The Church doesn’t run from these things; it redeems and re-purposes them for God’s glory.


“Advent isn’t in the Bible.”

This is another favorite of critics who claim, “If it’s not in Scripture, it’s not from God.” They argue that Advent, like Lent or the liturgical calendar itself, was invented later and is therefore “tradition of men.”

But that’s not how the Bible works. The concept of Advent — waiting for the Lord — is thoroughly biblical. The prophets spoke of it:

“The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light.” — Isaiah 9:2

John the Baptist lived it:

“Prepare the way of the Lord.” — Luke 3:4

And Christ Himself commanded His followers to “keep watch” for His return (Mark 13:35). The liturgical season of Advent simply formalizes that command into a rhythm of prayer and preparation.


2. The Truth About Advent

The Word “Advent”

“Advent” comes from the Latin adventus — meaning coming or arrival. In the early Church, Christians celebrated both the first coming of Christ (His birth) and His second coming (the end of time). The season was never about the sun’s return — it was about the Son’s return.

From the 4th century onward, the Church began setting aside several weeks before Christmas as a time of fasting, prayer, and repentance — not to mimic pagans, but to prepare the heart for the coming of Christ. Historical evidence shows Advent began in Spain and Gaul as a penitential season, similar to Lent, long before any “Christianization” of pagan customs.

“In the early centuries of the Church, Advent arose as a result of the fixed dating of Christmas.” — The Gospel Coalition (historical overview of Advent’s origin)

So Advent’s development wasn’t a compromise with paganism — it was a deepening of Christian theology.


The Wreath, Candles, and Colors

The Advent wreath’s four candles symbolize the four weeks of waiting — Hope, Peace, Joy, and Love — leading to the birth of Christ, the Light of the World (John 8:12). The growing light of each candle represents that Light overcoming darkness, just as Christ conquers sin.

The purple (or violet) candles represent penance and royalty; the rose candle on the third Sunday — Gaudete Sunday — marks joy and anticipation. These meanings are entirely rooted in Christian Scripture and liturgical symbolism.

Evergreens symbolize eternal life. Circles represent God’s unending love. Pagans might have used greenery to celebrate nature — but Catholics use it to celebrate divine grace.

As St. Paul said,

“Test everything; hold fast what is good.” — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
The Church didn’t steal pagan symbols — it purified them.


3. The Real Roots of Advent

Advent was formalized in the Western Church by the 4th or 5th century, as Christians began observing a preparatory season before Christmas much like Lent before Easter. In some regions, it lasted six weeks; in others, four.

The earliest documents — like the Council of Saragossa (380 A.D.) and the Sermons of St. Gregory the Great (6th century) — show that Advent was a season of penance, prayer, and anticipation. The emphasis was always the coming of Christ, not the cycles of nature.

That distinction matters. Paganism is about humanity’s attempt to manipulate the natural world for favor from the gods. Christianity is about God entering human history to save it. Advent reverses the logic of paganism: it’s not man reaching up, but God coming down.


4. The Modern Misunderstanding

Today, many of the same voices who call the Mass “pagan” now say the same about Advent, Christmas, and even Easter. They see any ritual, symbolism, or season as “idolatry.” But this rejection of the sacred is not biblical — it’s reactionary.

These accusations are not born from theology or reason; they’re born from hatred. They come from a deep suspicion of anything Catholic, from centuries of anti-Catholic propaganda that labeled the Church as “Babylon,” “the Whore,” and “the synagogue of Satan.”

It’s tragic, really — because the people who scream “pagan!” at Advent are attacking one of the most deeply biblical and Christ-centered seasons in the Christian year. Advent is not a festival of darkness; it’s the solemn lighting of the way toward the Light of the world.


5. Advent: The Christian Answer to Paganism

The Church has always taught that Christ is the fulfillment of every human longing — including the ones expressed in ancient myths and seasonal rituals. People throughout history have yearned for light, renewal, and redemption. Pagan cultures expressed that longing through symbols of fire and greenery, but Christianity revealed what they were really yearning for: Christ Himself.

In that sense, Advent isn’t pagan. It’s the answer to paganism. It’s the season when the ancient world’s hope becomes flesh and dwells among us.

As Pope Benedict XVI once said:

“Advent invites us to pause in silence to understand a presence… It is an invitation to understand that every event of history is a word spoken by God to us.” — Homily, December 2, 2006

That’s the beauty of Advent: it sanctifies time. It transforms winter darkness into spiritual light. It’s not about the birth of a sun god — it’s about the Incarnation of the Son of God.


6. Conclusion: The Light Has Come

When I light the candles of my Advent wreath, I don’t see echoes of pagan fire festivals or ancient superstitions. I see the promise of Isaiah fulfilled:

“The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light.” — Isaiah 9:2

I see the Church waiting in silence, hope, and faith — not for the turning of the seasons, but for the coming of the Savior.

Advent is not pagan. Advent is prophecy fulfilled. It is the heartbeat of the Church preparing for the Lord who was, is, and is to come.

“The night is far gone; the day is at hand.” — Romans 13:12


Notes & Selected Sources (Chicago Style)

  1. Alexander Hislop, The Two Babylons (Edinburgh: 1853).

  2. The Gospel Coalition, “The History of Advent,” 2020.

  3. Johann Hinrich Wichern and the Advent Wreath, Christian Heritage Fellowship (2021).

  4. Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§ 524–526.

  5. Pope Benedict XVI, Homily for First Sunday of Advent, December 2, 2006.

  6. Council of Saragossa (380 A.D.).

  7. St. Gregory the Great, Homilies on the Gospels, Book I.




About the Author



Chris M. Forte is a Catholic writer and storyteller based in Downtown San Diego. His work — from My Catholic Defense to The Italian Californian — explores faith, history, and identity. Through essays and stories, Chris confronts modern misconceptions about Catholicism and celebrates the timeless truth of the Church’s teachings. His writing reflects his conviction that the same light awaited in Advent still burns in every heart that seeks Christ.