Is Jesus the Messiah? A Catholic View—and What Others Believe

 

Is Jesus the Messiah? A Catholic View—and What Others Believe

In today’s world of instant information, opinion videos, podcasts, and endless debates, we’re constantly exposed to a wide range of views—especially when it comes to religion and the identity of Jesus. Thanks to the internet and platforms like YouTube, many Christians, Catholics included, are now encountering arguments and perspectives that challenge or reinterpret what we’ve long believed about Christ.

Whether it’s a Jewish scholar explaining why Jesus couldn’t be the Messiah, an atheist dissecting prophecy, or a Protestant interpreting Scripture differently, these voices are everywhere. And they can leave even faithful believers wondering: Have I truly understood who Jesus is? How can I be confident that He is the Messiah?

That’s a question I’ve been contemplating deeply—not because I doubt, but because I want to understand and articulate my faith more clearly. I believe we have a duty, as Catholics, to “always be ready to give an explanation to anyone who asks” (1 Peter 3:15). So this article is the result of my reflection: a personal reaffirmation of faith in Jesus as the Messiah, through the lens of Catholic tradition, while also exploring what others believe.

Is Jesus the Messiah? A Catholic View—and What Others Believe

As a Catholic and a believer in the truth of the Gospel, I affirm wholeheartedly that Jesus of Nazareth is the promised Messiah, the fulfillment of the Law and the Prophets, and the Son of the Living God. I believe, as the Church teaches, that Jesus alone is the Christ—the Anointed One foretold in Scripture—and that His life, death, and resurrection fulfilled God's plan for the salvation of Israel and the entire world.

But not everyone agrees. Jews, Protestants, atheists, and even mythicists all interpret the question of the Messiah—and the identity of Jesus—differently. In the spirit of clarity and charity, this article lays out the Catholic foundation for belief in Jesus as the Messiah while exploring how others see it.

---

✝️ The Catholic Christian View: Jesus Fulfills Messianic Prophecy

Catholics believe that Jesus is the Christ (from Christos, Greek for Messiah), and that His mission, miracles, crucifixion, and resurrection fulfilled the messianic expectations revealed throughout the Old Testament.

➤ Isaiah 7:14 – Born of a Virgin

“Behold, a young woman shall conceive and bear a son, and shall call his name Immanuel.” (Isaiah 7:14)
Fulfilled in Matthew 1:22–23 — Jesus is “God with us.”

➤ Micah 5:2 – Born in Bethlehem

“From you shall come forth for me one who is to be ruler in Israel...” (Micah 5:2)
Jesus was born in Bethlehem, the city of David.

➤ Isaiah 53 – The Suffering Servant

“He was wounded for our transgressions… by his stripes we are healed.” (Isaiah 53:5)
A perfect description of Christ’s Passion and redemptive death.

➤ Daniel 7:13–14 – The Divine Son of Man

“To him was given dominion and glory and kingdom… his kingdom shall not be destroyed.”
Jesus referred to Himself as the “Son of Man,” identifying with this divine figure.

➤ Psalm 22 – The Crucifixion Foretold

“They have pierced my hands and feet… they divide my garments among them.” (Psalm 22:16–18)
This was fulfilled literally at the crucifixion.

➤ Zechariah 12:10 – The Pierced One

“They shall look on him whom they have pierced and mourn for him...”
Quoted in John 19:37 as a direct reference to Christ’s death.

The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus is the eternal high priest, king, and prophet who came not to establish an earthly throne, but to inaugurate the Kingdom of God—present now in the Church, and to be fully revealed in the Second Coming.

---

✡️ The Jewish View: Jesus Was Not the Messiah

From a Jewish perspective, Jesus did not fulfill the biblical criteria for the Messiah:

• He did not rebuild the Temple.

• He did not bring peace to the world.

• He did not regather all Jews to Israel.

• He did not cause universal Torah observance or the full knowledge of God.

The Jewish Messiah is expected to be a human descendant of David, not divine, and will lead a national and global transformation. Many Jews regard Jesus as a sincere teacher or even a misunderstood reformer, but not the Messiah.

---

✝️ The Protestant View: Same Messiah, Distinct Interpretations

Protestants agree with Catholics that Jesus is the Messiah, but they interpret Scripture through Sola Scriptura (Scripture alone) and often emphasize:

• Personal faith in Jesus as the key to salvation.

• Jesus' atonement as the satisfying of God's justice.

• A focus on evangelism and end-times prophecy.

Evangelicals and fundamentalists often believe in a literal future reign of Christ on earth (premillennialism), while mainline Protestants might emphasize more symbolic or ethical interpretations.

---

🚫 The Atheist View: Jesus Was Not the Messiah—If He Existed

Most atheists reject the divine claims of Jesus entirely:

• Some accept Jesus as a historical figure—a Jewish preacher or reformer—whose followers later deified Him.

• Others believe the Gospel writers shaped their narratives to fit Old Testament “prophecies,” retroactively aligning His life with Scripture.

Common atheist critiques include:

• Prophecies are taken out of context.

• The Gospels are not historically reliable.

• Miracles and resurrection are theologically driven legends.

---

🧪 The Mythicist View: Jesus Never Existed at All

Mythicists believe Jesus is a literary or mythological figure, not a real person:

• They argue the Gospel story borrows from pagan dying-and-rising god myths.

• They view Jesus as a symbolic savior invented by early mystery religions and Jewish sects.

While this view is highly controversial and rejected by the majority of historians (including atheist ones), it remains popular among internet skeptics and fringe academics.

---

🧭 Comparison Summary

Viewpoint	Belief About Jesus as Messiah
Catholic	Jesus is the Messiah, God incarnate, fulfilled prophecy, reigns now, and will return
Jewish	Jesus did not fulfill the messianic tasks; the real Messiah has not yet come
Protestant	Jesus is Messiah; emphasis varies on personal faith, prophecy, or eschatology
Atheist	No divine Messiah; Jesus may be a moral teacher or legend; miracles and prophecy rejected
Mythicist	Jesus never existed as a historical figure; entirely mythological or literary construct

---

🕊️ My Catholic Conviction

As for me, I believe what the Catholic Church proclaims with confidence: that Jesus Christ is the Messiah, the fulfillment of all the Scriptures, the suffering servant of Isaiah, the divine Son of Man in Daniel, and the crucified and risen Lord foretold in the Psalms and prophets. He is God with us, and through His death and resurrection, He has opened the way to salvation for all who believe.

The Church, as His Body, continues His mission in the world today—proclaiming the Gospel, administering the sacraments, and awaiting the Second Coming, when Christ will fully reveal His kingdom in glory.

---

Interested in going deeper?
I recommend:

• Jesus of Nazareth by Pope Benedict XVI

• The Case for Jesus by Dr. Brant Pitre

• The Catechism of the Catholic Church, especially §§436–440, 668–682

About this Blog

Welcome to Why I Am Catholic

This is my personal blog, Why I Am Catholic—a space where I explore the beauty, truth, and reason behind the Catholic faith. Here, you’ll find not only the official teachings of the Catholic Church, but also my personal journey back home to the faith, shared with honesty, conviction, and humility.

When I offer personal opinions or reflections, I’ll make that clear. The truth deserves transparency, and I want to ensure no confusion between what the Church teaches and what I, as a Catholic layperson, believe and experience.

---

What This Blog Is—and Isn’t

This blog is part testimony, part resource, and part battleground.

Yes—battleground. Because let’s be honest: we live in a time when Catholicism is constantly under fire. From TikTok theologians to YouTube “exposés,” the Church is relentlessly misrepresented, distorted, or outright slandered.

Here, I take on questions like:

• “Is the Catholic Church really just baptized Babylonian paganism?”

• “Did Constantine create Catholicism?”

• “Do Catholics worship Mary and the saints?”

• “Is praying to a statue the same as idolatry?”

• “Which came first: the Church or the Bible?”

• “Is sola Scriptura biblically defensible?”

Spoiler alert: The Church has solid, historical, biblical answers to all of these—and I’m here to lay them out with clarity, sources, and the zeal of someone who’s wrestled with these questions firsthand.

---

A Note on Tools

Yes, I use tools like ChatGPT to assist with research, drafting, and outlining ideas. But the thoughts, prompts, editing, and direction come from me. This is a human blog, written by a real Catholic, not an AI echo chamber. Every post is reviewed and revised by me to ensure originality, integrity, and soul. More here..

---

My Journey Back to the Church

Like many, I wandered. I questioned. I wrestled with teachings I didn’t understand—or didn’t want to. But something kept pulling me back. Something deeper than doctrine or ritual. A Person. A presence. A Church that would not let me go.

I’ll share that full story soon. But know this: I didn’t come back because I was guilted into it. I came back because I found truth, mercy, and beauty in a Church I had once misunderstood.

If you’re a former or lapsed Catholic, or if you’ve never been Catholic but feel drawn to something deeper, this space is for you.

---

The Church Is Not What You’ve Been Told

Forget what pop culture or clickbait videos told you. The Catholic Church is not some cold, judgmental fortress obsessed with rules and guilt. Yes, we believe in truth—and yes, some things are morally non-negotiable. But the heart of the Church is not law. It’s grace.

The Church is, as Pope Francis reminds us, “a field hospital for sinners,” not a museum of the spiritually elite. All of us—saints in progress, sinners in need—are welcomed, not because we’re worthy, but because He is merciful.

So if you’re burdened by sins, shame, or past mistakes… don’t stay away. Walk into a parish. Find a priest. Go to Confession. You won’t be met with judgment—you’ll be met with open arms, a listening heart, and a way back to peace.

No Catholic church I’ve ever walked into has turned someone away who came in with sincerity.

---

Why This Blog Exists

This blog exists because truth matters.

Because false claims need to be corrected.
Because wounded hearts deserve healing, not half-truths.
Because the Catholic Church—despite all her flaws, scars, and human messiness—is still the Bride of Christ. Still the Church founded by Jesus. Still the guardian of the fullness of Christian faith.

So yes, I will defend her.
I will expose lies.
I will counter the slander.
I will help bring truth back into the light—where it belongs.

---

Start Here

Below you’ll find a collection of articles and reflections—some theological, some historical, some personal—that map out my return to the Church and the reasons I believe Catholicism holds the fullness of truth.

Read them with an open heart. Question them. Pray about them. And if you feel even a faint pull in your soul, don’t ignore it.

You’re not alone. You’re not too far gone. And the Church is still here—waiting to welcome you home.

For lapsed Catholics: How Do I Come Home?

For new Catholics: Becoming Catholic? The Beginner's Guide To a Life of Faith

_____________________________

 The Quiet Way I Evangelize: A Catholic’s Personal Witness to the Truth

Why I Believe in God & The Church He Founded

Why I Am a Catholic: The Roman Catholic Church Is the temporal Kingdom of God on Earth

Church History: If Jesus & the Apostles were Jews, why aren't we Catholic Christians Jewish?: From the Nazarenes to the Rise of Gentile Christianity: The Transformation of the Early Church and the Establishment of Papal Supremacy

The True Name of the Church and Why I Am Catholic

Why I’m Catholic: Overcoming Distrust of Organized Religion and Deep-Seated Protestant Misconceptions

The Catholic Church & The Gospel: Keeping it Simple but True

Are Catholics "Saved": The Catholic Teaching on Salvation

Why I cannot agree with sola scriptura

Why I Am Catholic: Which Came First: The Church or the Bible?

From Jewish Roots to Roman Leadership: The Evolution of the Catholic Church and the Rise of the Papacy

Why I'm Catholic: Ancestry & Tradition: Italian Catholicism

The Catholic Church's Leadership Structure: Influences from Jewish and Roman Traditions

 

From Cult to Church: Why the Catholic Church Is Not a Cult — Even If Christianity Began Like One

Why would someone leave a cult like the Jehovah's Witnesses… only to join the Catholic Church?
Isn't Catholicism just another high-control religion?
Isn't it also obsessed with authority, loyalty, doctrine, and ritual?
Isn’t it, some say, just a more elaborate cult?

No. It isn’t.

And understanding why means being honest about the uncomfortable truth at the heart of Christianity’s origins:
Yes, Christianity began with many cult-like traits.
Yes, it was once a small, radical, apocalyptic sect centered around a single charismatic man.
Yes, it demanded everything from its followers — total allegiance, separation from family, the surrender of property and social norms.

But here’s the difference:

Cults consume people. The Church builds people.
Cults collapse when the leader dies. The Church was born when He did.
Cults shun the sinner. The Church invites him to supper.

So if you've escaped a group like Jehovah’s Witnesses — one that isolates, disfellowships, controls, and breaks families — and you're wondering if the Catholic Church is just another version of that… the answer is no.

And here’s why — from history, from theology, from lived experience.

---

Christianity Began with Cult-Like Traits

Let’s be honest: Jesus sounded like a cult leader to outsiders.

He demanded radical allegiance:

“If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother… he cannot be my disciple.”
— Luke 14:26

He predicted the imminent end of the world:

“This generation will not pass away until all these things take place.”
— Matthew 24:34

He asked His followers to give up everything:

“Sell all you have… then come, follow me.”
— Luke 18:22

Early Christians lived in a communal environment:

“They had everything in common and gave to anyone as he had need.”
— Acts 2:44–45

They believed the world was on the brink of divine transformation.

According to sociologists like Rodney Stark (The Rise of Christianity), and historians like Bart Ehrman, early Christianity bore all the hallmarks of an apocalyptic Jewish sect:

• A tight inner circle

• A strong us-vs-them worldview

• Belief in a soon-coming end

• A rejection of mainstream religion

• A founder who was seen as divinely chosen

But it didn’t stay that way.

---

The Messianic Fever of First-Century Judaism

The world Jesus entered was already teeming with cults and messianic movements.
Roman occupation had pushed Jewish hopes for liberation to the breaking point.

The Jewish people expected a Messiah — a deliverer who would restore the kingdom of David and throw off foreign rule. As the historian Josephus notes, many claimed that title.

Some gathered large followings:

• Judas the Galilean led a revolt over Roman taxation.

• The Egyptian prophet led thousands into the wilderness promising signs.

• Simon bar Giora later led rebels in the Jewish War.

They all died. Their cults ended with them.

But Jesus’ death did not end His following. It ignited it.

---

What Changed?

Three things set Christianity apart from every other movement:

1. The Resurrection Claim

Jesus wasn’t simply executed and mourned. His disciples claimed He rose from the dead.
That claim didn’t fade — it grew. And His followers were willing to die rather than deny it.

“If Christ has not been raised, then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain.”
— 1 Corinthians 15:14

2. Decentralized Leadership

Where cults rely on a single infallible voice, Christianity expanded through a community of witnesses: Peter, James, Paul, John, and more. They founded churches, appointed successors, and passed on teachings.

3. From Emotion to Theology

Cults run on charisma. But early Christians wrote letters, debated doctrines, and grounded their faith in Scripture, history, and reason. By the second century, theologians like Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, and Tertullian were defending the faith not with feelings, but with arguments.

---

Why the Catholic Church Is Not a Cult

Some ex-cult survivors fear any organized religion. Rightly so. Cults use fear and control to dominate people’s lives.

Here’s why the Catholic Church — even with its rituals, hierarchy, and authority — is fundamentally different.

---

1. The Catholic Church Does Not Shun or Disfellowship

Jehovah’s Witnesses practice disfellowshipping — cutting off all contact, even between family members, if someone leaves or questions the group.

The Catholic Church does not do this.

Yes, it does practice excommunication — a formal recognition that someone is out of communion with the Church due to grave public sin or heresy.
But even then:

• The goal is not punishment, but repentance.

• The Church continues to pray for the person.

• Family and friends are never told to cut them off.

“Excommunication is intended to bring the person to repentance and return to communion. It is not meant to cast them out forever.”
— Catechism of the Catholic Church, §1463

As canon lawyer Edward Peters writes:

“Excommunication bars one from the sacraments, not from family, friendship, or hope.”

Jesus modeled this.

“While Jesus was having dinner at Matthew’s house, many tax collectors and sinners came and ate with him.”
— Matthew 9:10

He didn’t avoid the fallen. He sat beside them.

---

2. You Can Question, Doubt, and Disagree

Cults demand obedience. The Catholic Church demands truth — and truth can handle questions.

The Church teaches the primacy of conscience:

“Man has the right to act in conscience and in freedom… He must not be forced to act contrary to his conscience.”
— CCC, §1782

Dissent exists within the Church. Dialogue happens.

Some of the greatest saints and theologians — Augustine, Aquinas, Newman — questioned, struggled, even got things wrong. But they were part of a living tradition that allowed for growth and complexity.

---

3. Families Are Not Weaponized

Cults cut off dissenters to maintain control. The Church holds on through love and witness.

No parent is told to reject a child who leaves the faith.
No spouse is told to abandon a partner who stops believing.

“The Church must be a place of mercy freely given, where everyone can feel welcomed, loved, forgiven, and encouraged to live the good life of the Gospel.”
— Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium, §114

---

The Catholic Church Is Not Afraid of the Other

What makes Catholicism better — in my eyes — is precisely its refusal to shun the different, the doubtful, the sinner.

It embraces. It hopes. It waits.

That’s why could never join a group like Jehovah’s Witnesses — where love had conditions — but entered a Church that stayed in my life even when I walked away from it.

It was not shunning that brought me back.

It was love.

---

Final Thought: Built on Mercy, Not Control

The Catholic Church is ancient. It is flawed. It is human.

But it is not a cult.

It is a family — sometimes a broken one — but always a family.

And like any true family, it does not slam the door behind you when you leave.
It leaves a light in the window.

---

Key Quotes

“The Church is not a tollhouse. It is the house of the Father.”
— Pope Francis

“I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.”
— Jesus, Mark 2:17

“Where Peter is, there is the Church.”
— St. Ambrose

God Doesn't Make Mistakes

 Does God Make Mistakes? A Catholic Perspective on Human Suffering, Disabilities, and Gender Identity

The Nature of God: Perfect and Without Error

From a Christian and Catholic perspective, God does not make mistakes. As Scripture affirms, God is all-powerful, all-knowing, and perfectly loving:

• Deuteronomy 32:4 – "The Rock, His work is perfect, for all His ways are justice. A God of faithfulness and without iniquity, just and upright is He."

• Psalm 139:13-14 – "For You formed my inward parts; You knitted me together in my mother’s womb. I praise You, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made."

Everything that exists is either created directly by God or allowed by Him for reasons beyond our full understanding. This includes children born with medical, mental, or physical conditions, as well as those who struggle with gender identity and sexual orientation. But how do we reconcile these realities with an all-loving, all-powerful Creator?

Suffering and Disabilities: Not a Mistake, But a Mystery of Love

Many people ask why a loving God would allow children to be born with disabilities, illnesses, or deformities. The Catholic Church teaches that human suffering is a profound mystery, but it is not purposeless. While suffering is a result of the fallen world (Genesis 3), it can serve a redemptive purpose and be a means to reveal God's glory:

• John 9:2-3 – When Jesus was asked whether a man’s blindness was due to his sin or his parents' sin, He responded: “It was not that this man sinned, or his parents, but that the works of God might be displayed in him.”

• 2 Corinthians 12:9 – St. Paul speaks of his own suffering, saying: “My grace is sufficient for you, for My power is made perfect in weakness.”

The Church teaches that every human being, regardless of their physical or mental condition, has infinite dignity because they are created in the image of God (Genesis 1:27). Disabilities and challenges are not divine errors; rather, they can be invitations to greater love, compassion, and spiritual growth, both for the individual and for those around them.

LGBTQ and Transgender Identity: A Catholic Understanding

Regarding gender and sexual identity, some people feel that their bodies do not align with their internal sense of self. Does this mean God made a mistake? Catholic teaching emphasizes that God creates each person with purpose and dignity, but also acknowledges that the world, including human nature, has been affected by original sin.

• Matthew 19:4 – "Have you not read that He who created them from the beginning made them male and female?"

• Jeremiah 1:5 – "Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you, and before you were born, I consecrated you."

The Church recognizes that gender dysphoria and same-sex attraction are real experiences and calls for deep compassion and understanding. However, Catholic theology teaches that our biological sex is part of God's intentional design. While struggles with identity can be challenging, the Church invites individuals to seek their true identity in Christ and to live in accordance with God's moral order.

God's Plan and Our Response

Rather than seeing physical and psychological struggles as divine mistakes, Catholic theology encourages us to see them as part of the larger mystery of human existence and salvation. While some aspects of human suffering remain difficult to understand, the Church offers several responses:

1. Trust in Divine Providence – We may not always comprehend why suffering and struggles exist, but we trust that God has a plan greater than our understanding (Isaiah 55:8-9).

2. Compassion and Support – As followers of Christ, we are called to support those who struggle, whether due to illness, disability, or gender identity, treating them with love and dignity (Galatians 6:2).

3. Redemptive Suffering – The Catholic faith teaches that suffering can be united with Christ’s suffering on the cross, giving it meaning and purpose (Colossians 1:24).

Conclusion

God does not make mistakes. Every person is created with dignity and purpose, even in the midst of struggles, suffering, and questions of identity. While we may not fully understand the reasons behind certain challenges, our faith assures us that God’s love is ever-present and that He calls each of us to holiness and trust in His divine wisdom.

The Feast of Saint Joseph: La Tavola di San Giuseppe

 

The Feast of Saint Joseph: La Tavola di San Giuseppe

Introduction

The Feast of Saint Joseph, or La Festa di San Giuseppe, is a deeply cherished tradition in Catholicism and among Italians worldwide. Celebrated on March 19th, this feast honors Saint Joseph, the earthly father of Jesus and patron saint of workers, fathers, and the universal Church. In Italy, the day is recognized as a national holiday, much like Father’s Day, and is observed with religious ceremonies, grand feasts, and acts of charity. Italian-American communities, particularly Catholic ones, have maintained and adapted these traditions in the United States, ensuring that Saint Joseph’s Day remains a vital cultural and religious celebration.

The Significance of Saint Joseph in Catholicism

Saint Joseph is venerated as a model of humility, faith, and hard work. Though little is written about him in the Bible, his role in salvation history is profound. As the protector of the Holy Family, Joseph demonstrated unwavering obedience to God’s will, providing for Mary and Jesus through his labor as a carpenter. Pope Pius IX declared him the patron of the universal Church in 1870, solidifying his importance in Catholic devotion.

The Church has long recognized Saint Joseph as a special intercessor, particularly for workers, fathers, and those in need. His feast day is marked with prayers, special Masses, and celebrations that reflect his virtues of generosity and humility.

La Tavola di San Giuseppe: The Traditional St. Joseph’s Table

One of the most beloved traditions associated with Saint Joseph’s Day is the Tavola di San Giuseppe (St. Joseph’s Table), a communal feast that dates back to the Middle Ages in Sicily. According to legend, during a time of severe drought and famine, Sicilians prayed to Saint Joseph for relief. When the rains finally came, they prepared a grand banquet in his honor, offering food to the poor in thanksgiving. This tradition continues today as a way of honoring Saint Joseph’s spirit of kindness and care for the less fortunate.

A traditional Tavola di San Giuseppe includes a beautifully adorned altar with three tiers, representing the Holy Trinity. The table is filled with an abundance of food, all meatless in accordance with Lenten traditions. Common dishes include:

• Fava beans – Symbolizing good luck and abundance, as they were one of the few crops that sustained people during the famine.

• Bread in symbolic shapes – Breads shaped like crosses, staffs, and Joseph’s beard are central to the feast.

• Pasta con sarde – A Sicilian dish made with pasta, sardines, fennel, and breadcrumbs.

• Zeppole di San Giuseppe – Traditional cream-filled pastries associated with the feast.

• Citrus fruits, vegetables, and wine – Reflecting the bounty of the harvest.

The feast is often accompanied by prayers, the recitation of the Rosary, and communal dining, with an emphasis on feeding the poor and those in need.

Saint Joseph’s Day in Italy

In Italy, March 19th is not only a religious observance but also a public holiday. The day is akin to Father’s Day, with families celebrating their fathers and grandfathers, recognizing their dedication and sacrifice in the spirit of Saint Joseph. Children often give gifts to their fathers, and communities hold processions, parades, and special Masses in his honor.

In southern Italy and Sicily, Saint Joseph’s Day is especially revered. Many towns hold reenactments of the Holy Family seeking shelter, with participants dressed as Joseph, Mary, and Jesus, symbolizing Joseph’s role as a provider and protector. Public feasts are common, and it is customary for those who have had prayers answered through Saint Joseph’s intercession to host a Tavola di San Giuseppe as an act of thanksgiving.

Italian-American Celebrations in the United States

Italian-American Catholic communities have brought the rich traditions of Saint Joseph’s Day to the United States, particularly in cities with large Italian populations such as New Orleans, New York, and Chicago. Parishes and cultural organizations organize Saint Joseph’s Tables, Masses, processions, and charitable events to honor the saint.

In New Orleans, for example, the celebration is particularly grand, with elaborate altars, public feasts, and a deep-rooted tradition of generosity. Bakeries and restaurants prepare zeppole and other festive foods, while churches host Masses and community gatherings.

Saint Joseph’s Day at Our Lady of the Rosary, San Diego

Our Lady of the Rosary (OLR), an Italian National Parish in San Diego’s historic Little Italy, has long been a cornerstone of Italian Catholic traditions in the region. The parish is known for hosting grand celebrations for various saint feast days, including La Festa di San Giuseppe.

Each year, OLR’s Saint Joseph’s Day celebration is one of its most anticipated events, bringing together the community for a special Mass, a traditional Tavola di San Giuseppe, and acts of charity. The event typically includes a solemn procession, beautifully adorned altars, and a communal feast featuring classic Italian dishes associated with the holiday.

Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, recent celebrations were either postponed or conducted with limited in-person attendance. In 2020, rather than holding the traditional Mass and luncheon fundraiser, the parish shared an article about the feast on its website and in its bulletin. While these adaptations were necessary, they could not replace the deep sense of faith and community that normally accompanies the annual event.

To offer a glimpse of what a traditional Saint Joseph’s Day Mass at Our Lady of the Rosary looks like, I am sharing a video from the 2019 celebration. Though it was recorded on a cell phone, I hope it captures the beauty and solemnity of the occasion. Below is a short clip of the opening procession, and you can view the full video here.

For more photos and a deeper look at past celebrations, you can find additional resources here. If you would like to learn more about Saint Joseph’s Day and its significance, you can read about it here.

Visit Our Lady of the Rosary

If you are ever in Southern California and want to experience an authentic Saint Joseph’s Day celebration, consider visiting Our Lady of the Rosary in San Diego’s Little Italy. Attending this feast day is a wonderful way to immerse yourself in Italian Catholic traditions and devotion.

Our Lady of the Rosary

• Address: 1629 Columbia St., San Diego, CA 92101

• Email: parish@olrsd.org

• Phone: 619-234-4820

• Website: OLRSD.org

Conclusion

The Feast of Saint Joseph is a cherished tradition that bridges faith, culture, and community. Whether celebrated in Italy, the United States, or anywhere with a strong Catholic presence, the feast serves as a reminder of Saint Joseph’s virtues of humility, protection, and charity. From grand altars and feasts to intimate family gatherings, the day continues to be a testament to the enduring devotion to this beloved saint.

As Italian-American Catholics maintain and adapt these traditions, Saint Joseph’s Day remains a beautiful expression of faith, gratitude, and communal spirit. If you ever have the chance to experience a Tavola di San Giuseppe or attend a Saint Joseph’s Day Mass, it is an event that truly embodies the heart of Italian Catholic culture.

Grazie! Auguri!

The Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter

 The Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter

While theology and doctrinal truth are undeniably important, it was history that ultimately drew me back to the Catholic Church. The relic of the Chair of Saint Peter, dating back at least to the 9th century, and the Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter, celebrated since the 4th century, serve as profound testaments to the Church's long and unbroken tradition. Yes, while the Cathedra Petri, the chair from which the Pope—the Bishop of Rome and head of the Catholic Church—teaches, has its origins in the Middle Ages, it stands in stark contrast to the podium or pulpit of a Protestant pastor at a Calvary Chapel or Evangelical Free Church, which may well have been purchased from IKEA just yesterday. Let's take a deeper look at this sacred chair and the feast that commemorates it.

Introduction

The Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter is a significant celebration in the Catholic Church, observed annually on February 22. This feast honors the authority and mission entrusted to Saint Peter by Jesus Christ and symbolizes the unity and guidance of the papacy. The “Chair” represents the spiritual authority conferred upon Peter as the leader of the Church, a role that continues through his successors, the Popes.

Biblical Foundations

The foundation of this feast is rooted in Matthew 16:18-19, where Jesus declares to Peter:

"And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of Hades will not overcome it. I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven." This passage highlights Peter’s unique role in the early Christian community and the establishment of apostolic succession within the Church.

Historical Significance

The celebration of the Chair of Saint Peter dates back to the 4th century, when the early Christians honored Peter’s role as the first Bishop of Rome. Historically, the term “chair” (Latin: cathedra) signifies the teaching authority of a bishop. In Rome, there were originally two commemorations: one marking Peter’s leadership in Antioch and another in Rome. Over time, these were unified into a single feast observed on February 22.

The History and Usage of the Chair of Saint Peter

The Chair of Saint Peter is a relic housed in St. Peter’s Basilica in Vatican City. It is traditionally believed to be an ancient wooden throne used by Saint Peter himself. The relic is an important symbol of the Pope's authority, serving as a physical representation of apostolic succession and the leadership of the Catholic Church.

The chair, which dates back at least to the 9th century, was venerated by early Christians and was believed to have been used by Saint Peter when he led the Church in Rome. Some scholars suggest that it was constructed or modified during the Carolingian period (8th-9th century). Over the centuries, the chair has undergone several restorations, but its core wooden structure has been preserved.

The chair itself is made of wood and is heavily reinforced with later additions of ivory and metalwork. Historical accounts indicate that it was used in significant papal ceremonies, serving as a throne symbolizing the Pope's supreme authority over the Church.

The Chair of Saint Peter and the Chair of Moses

The Chair of Saint Peter holds a theological parallel to the Chair of Moses, which symbolized the teaching authority of Jewish religious leaders in ancient times. Just as Jewish teachers sat in the Chair of Moses to interpret the Law, Peter was enthroned by Christ as the leader of the New Covenant. This transition signified the fulfillment and transformation of the old covenant into the Kingdom of God on Earth, with Peter serving as its earthly steward.

In this role, Peter can be understood as a prime minister in Christ’s kingdom, akin to the office established during King David’s reign. In Davidic times, the king appointed a steward who held the keys to the kingdom and governed in the king’s name. This analogy is further reinforced in Isaiah 22:22, which speaks of giving authority through the “keys of the house of David”—a passage that finds fulfillment in Peter’s commission in Matthew 16:19.

The Reliquary: Bernini’s Monumental “Chair of Saint Peter”

To protect and venerate this ancient relic, Gian Lorenzo Bernini designed a grand reliquary known as the Cathedra Petri (Chair of Peter) in the 17th century. Completed in 1666, this stunning Baroque masterpiece is housed in the apse of St. Peter’s Basilica. The reliquary serves as both an artistic and theological expression of the Pope's authority.

The Cathedra Petri is an elaborate gilded-bronze structure, supported by statues of four Doctors of the Church: Saint Ambrose, Saint Augustine, Saint John Chrysostom, and Saint Athanasius. Above the chair, a golden, radiant window featuring the Holy Spirit in the form of a dove illuminates the space, symbolizing divine inspiration and guidance.

The relic itself is encased within this grand artistic structure, ensuring its preservation while highlighting its importance. The composition blends sculpture, architecture, and light, creating an awe-inspiring tribute to the papal authority established by Saint Peter.

Symbolism and Meaning

The chair itself is a symbol of teaching and authority, reflecting the Pope’s role as the supreme pastor of the Catholic Church. The celebration of this feast is a reaffirmation of the unity of the Church under the leadership of the Pope, tracing its lineage back to Saint Peter.

One of the most notable artistic representations of this authority is Bernini’s “Chair of Saint Peter”, a grand Baroque sculpture in St. Peter’s Basilica in Vatican City. This masterpiece encloses a wooden relic believed to be an ancient chair used by Saint Peter.

Observances and Traditions

The Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter is marked by special liturgical celebrations, particularly in Rome at St. Peter’s Basilica. Key aspects of its observance include:

• Special Masses emphasizing the role of Peter and his successors.

• Papal Reflections, where the Pope often speaks on the significance of unity and leadership in the Church.

• The Veneration of Relics, including the Chair of Saint Peter housed in the Vatican.

Modern Relevance

In today’s world, this feast remains a powerful reminder of the Church’s commitment to apostolic succession and the Pope’s role in leading and guiding the faithful. It underscores the importance of unity in the Church and encourages Catholics to remain steadfast in their faith and adherence to Church teachings.

Conclusion

The Feast of the Chair of Saint Peter is more than a historical observance; it is a celebration of the unbroken spiritual authority that has guided the Catholic Church for centuries. Through this feast, Catholics reflect on the legacy of Saint Peter and the enduring role of the papacy in maintaining the faith and teachings of the Church. The Chair of Saint Peter, housed in Bernini’s magnificent reliquary, remains a testament to the deep-rooted tradition and significance of the papal office.

The Catholic Church’s Stance on Immigration and Border Enforcement: Can a Devout Catholic Support “Enforcement First” Immigration Policies?

 

The Catholic Church’s Stance on Immigration and Border Enforcement

The Catholic Church's stance on immigration is rooted in the principles of human dignity, compassion, and the rule of law. While the Church advocates for the humane treatment of migrants, it also acknowledges the rights of nations to regulate their borders for the common good.

Church Teaching on Immigration and Border Enforcement

The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC) articulates a balanced view on immigration. It recognizes the right of individuals to migrate in search of better living conditions and the corresponding right of nations to control their borders. Specifically, CCC 2241 states:

"The more prosperous nations are obliged, to the extent they are able, to welcome the foreigner in search of the security and the means of livelihood which he cannot find in his country of origin. Public authorities should see to it that the natural right is respected that places a guest under the protection of those who receive him."

This passage underscores the duty of wealthier nations to assist migrants while also emphasizing the role of public authorities in regulating immigration to ensure the common good.

Pope Francis' Perspective

Pope Francis has been a vocal advocate for the rights and dignity of migrants. In a letter to U.S. bishops dated February 11, 2025, he expressed concern over policies that criminalize migrants, stating that approaches based solely on force "will end badly." He emphasized the need for compassion and solidarity, urging that migration policies be grounded in truth and respect for human dignity (usccb.org).

While the Pope calls for the humane treatment of migrants, he does not advocate for open borders. Instead, he acknowledges the right of nations to control their borders but cautions against policies that dehumanize individuals fleeing hardship. His position is a call to balance mercy with law and order.

Can a Devout Catholic Support “Enforcement First” Immigration Policies?

Yes. A devout Catholic can and should support lawful and just border enforcement policies while remaining faithful to Catholic teaching. Being pro-border security is not incompatible with Catholicism—rather, it aligns with the Church’s teachings when balanced with justice, charity, and prudence.

The Catholic faith teaches that nations have the right and duty to:

1. Protect their citizens from security threats, organized crime, and human trafficking.
2. Ensure economic stability and social order by preventing unchecked migration that could strain resources.
3. Enforce just laws while treating migrants with dignity and respect.
4. Address the root causes of migration, such as poverty, violence, and corruption in home countries.

Catholics must reject cruelty toward migrants, but they are not morally obligated to support open borders or policies that ignore the rule of law. Immigration must be handled in a way that reflects both mercy and justice—a balance between welcoming the stranger (Matthew 25:35) and ensuring lawful, orderly migration (Romans 13:1-7).

A Practical and Faithful Approach to Immigration

From a Catholic perspective, supporting an "enforcement first" immigration policy aligns with Church teaching when it balances the rule of law with compassion. Such an approach emphasizes:

• Sovereignty and Security: Nations have a responsibility to protect their citizens and maintain order, which includes regulating who enters the country.
• Economic Stability and Social Cohesion: Controlled immigration ensures that resources are managed effectively and that societal structures remain stable.
• Upholding Human Dignity: While enforcing laws, it's imperative to treat all individuals with respect, ensuring that policies do not lead to unnecessary suffering or discrimination.

History has demonstrated that granting amnesty without robust enforcement measures can lead to increased illegal immigration, as seen with the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act. Therefore, a policy that prioritizes enforcement seeks to prevent such outcomes by ensuring that immigration laws are respected and upheld.

Conclusion: A Catholic Case for Border Security and Lawful Immigration

A faithful Catholic can support strong border security and enforcement while still upholding the moral obligation to treat migrants with dignity. The Catholic perspective calls for both justice and mercy, meaning that while we should support humane treatment of migrants, we must also uphold the rule of law.

A balanced immigration policy should prioritize enforcement first, ensuring that existing laws are respected and enforced before considering any pathways for legal status. This approach does not contradict Catholic values but rather reflects a just and orderly system that serves the common good.

In short, Catholics are not required to advocate for open borders, nor should they support policies that encourage lawlessness and exploitation. True Catholic social teaching calls for prudence, justice, and charity—all of which can be achieved by enforcing immigration laws compassionately, but firmly.