Showing posts with label protestant. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protestant. Show all posts

Friday, August 28, 2026

Catholics and Protestants: Is Christianity an Invisible Movement or a Visible Kingdom? A Catholic Reflection on the Real Difference





Catholics and Protestants: Is Christianity an Invisible Movement or a Visible Kingdom?

A Catholic Reflection on the Real Difference

By Chris M. Forte

Abstract

Catholics and Protestants often debate Scripture, Tradition, the papacy, Mary, the Eucharist, justification, saints, purgatory, and Church authority. These are important disagreements, but in my view they all flow from one deeper question: What is the Church?

Many Protestants understand the true Church primarily as the invisible communion of all true believers. Visible churches, pastors, elders, denominations, and institutions may be useful, biblical, and even necessary for good order, but they are not usually understood as the essential visible Kingdom structure established by Christ. Catholicism sees the matter differently. To Catholics, Christianity is not merely a spiritual movement of believers. It is the renewed and fulfilled Davidic Kingdom of Israel: the Kingdom of God established by Jesus Christ, the Son of David. Christ is King; Mary is the Queen Mother; Peter and his successors hold the keys as chief stewards; and the bishops, successors of the apostles, govern in communion with the successor of Peter.

This article argues that the most fundamental Catholic-Protestant difference is ecclesiology: whether Christianity is primarily an invisible fellowship of believers or the visible, sacramental Kingdom Christ founded in history.




Introduction: The Question Underneath Every Catholic-Protestant Debate

When Catholics and Protestants argue, we usually go straight to the familiar topics: the Bible, Tradition, faith and works, the pope, Mary, confession, the Mass, purgatory, or the saints.

Those issues matter. I am not dismissing them. But I have come to believe they are not the deepest issue.

The deepest issue is this:

What did Jesus actually establish?

Did He leave behind a Bible and a loose spiritual fellowship of believers? Did He inspire a movement that later became organized for practical reasons? Did He create a Church only in the invisible sense, known perfectly to God, while visible churches remain temporary human arrangements?

Or did Jesus establish a visible Kingdom, with covenant authority, apostles, sacraments, hierarchy, and a steward who holds the keys?

That is the real dividing line.

In my view, Catholicism makes the most sense when we stop thinking of Christianity as merely a “religion” in the modern private sense and start thinking biblically. Jesus did not simply come to launch a new denomination, philosophy, or inspirational movement. He came as the Messiah, the Son of David, to establish the Kingdom of God. That Kingdom is not merely emotional, symbolic, or invisible. It is historical, sacramental, apostolic, and visible.

That is why I am Catholic.

Not because every Catholic leader has been holy. Not because every pope, bishop, priest, or lay Catholic has lived up to the Gospel. Obviously, they have not. The sins of Catholics are real. The scandals are real. The failures are real.

But human failure does not erase divine institution.

The Catholic claim is not that Catholics are better people. The Catholic claim is that Christ founded a visible Church, and that this Church is the renewed Kingdom of Israel made present in history.




I. The Protestant View: The Invisible Church of All True Believers

To be fair, Protestantism is not one single thing. Lutherans, Anglicans, Presbyterians, Baptists, Methodists, Pentecostals, Evangelicals, and non-denominational Christians do not all understand the Church in exactly the same way. Some Protestants have bishops. Some have elders. Some have formal confessions. Some have liturgy. Some are very structured. Others are much more informal.

So I do not want to misrepresent Protestants.

Historic Protestantism does not necessarily deny the visible church. For example, the Westminster Confession of Faith, Chapter 25, distinguishes between the invisible Church and the visible Church. It says the invisible Church consists of the whole number of the elect gathered under Christ, while the visible Church consists of those throughout the world who profess the true religion and their children.

The Augsburg Confession, Article VII, says the Church is the congregation of saints in which the Gospel is rightly taught and the sacraments are rightly administered. The Anglican Thirty-Nine Articles, Article XIX, define the visible Church as a congregation where the pure Word of God is preached and the sacraments are duly ministered.

So again, I am not saying Protestants reject all visible structure. They do not.

But there is a common Protestant instinct that differs sharply from Catholicism: the true Church is ultimately the invisible communion of true believers known fully to God. Visible organization matters, but it is not usually seen as the essential Kingdom structure Christ established in the Catholic sense.

A pastor, elders, local congregation, denomination, or church board may be beneficial. It may even be considered biblically appropriate. But if a structure becomes corrupt, Protestants usually believe Christians may separate, reform, reorganize, or establish another visible church around the true preaching of the Gospel.

That is why Protestantism can multiply into thousands of denominations while still claiming spiritual unity in the invisible Church.

The Catholic view is different.

For Catholics, the visible structure is not merely practical. It is not just a helpful container for Christian spirituality. It belongs to the nature of the Church Christ founded.




II. The Catholic View: The Church Is Visible and Spiritual

Catholicism does not deny that the Church has an invisible spiritual dimension. Of course she does. Grace is invisible. The soul is invisible. God alone knows perfectly who is truly faithful. Not everyone visibly inside the Church is holy, and not everyone visibly outside her boundaries is without grace.

But Catholicism refuses to separate the invisible Church from the visible Church as if Jesus founded one and man invented the other.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that the Church is “both visible and spiritual,” a “hierarchical society” and the “Mystical Body of Christ.” That is the Catholic both/and.

The Church is visible because the Incarnation is visible.

The Word became flesh. God entered history. Christ did not save us by remaining distant, abstract, and invisible. He took on a real body, spoke real words, touched real people, chose real apostles, gave real sacraments, and founded a real Church.

So why would His Church be merely invisible?

Catholicism is sacramental because Christianity itself is incarnational. God uses visible signs to communicate invisible grace. Water is used in Baptism. Bread and wine become the Eucharist. Human words become absolution. Human hands ordain. Human shepherds govern.

This is not a betrayal of the Gospel. This is how the Gospel takes flesh in history.




III. Jesus Did Not Merely Start a Movement

One of the most important biblical facts is that Jesus preached the Kingdom of God.

He did not merely preach “accept Me into your heart” in the individualistic modern sense. He did not merely gather people into a loose spiritual network. He proclaimed that the Kingdom was at hand.

That matters.

The Kingdom of God was not a vague religious feeling. It was the fulfillment of Israel’s hopes. Jesus was announced as the Son of David. Gabriel told Mary that her Son would receive the throne of His father David and that His Kingdom would have no end. Jesus entered Jerusalem as King. He was crucified under the title “King of the Jews.”

In other words, Jesus’ mission was royal, covenantal, and messianic.

This is the foundation of Catholic ecclesiology.

If Jesus is the Davidic King, then the Church is not merely a voluntary association of believers. It is the renewed and fulfilled Davidic Kingdom of Israel. It is Israel restored, expanded, and universalized in Christ.

The Catholic Church is not simply “organized religion.” She is not merely a denomination. She is the visible Kingdom community established by the King.

That does not mean the Church is already perfect in her members. The Kingdom is already present but not yet fully consummated. The weeds and wheat grow together until the end. But the Kingdom is truly present.

That is why the Catholic Church can be both holy and filled with sinners. She is holy because Christ is holy, her sacraments are holy, her doctrine is holy, and her mission is holy. She is filled with sinners because we are the ones Christ came to save.




IV. The Twelve Apostles and the Renewed Israel

Jesus did not randomly choose twelve apostles.

He chose twelve because Israel had twelve tribes.

That act was not accidental. It was symbolic, covenantal, and governmental. Jesus was reconstituting Israel around Himself.

He even told the apostles that they would sit on twelve thrones judging the twelve tribes of Israel. Thrones and judgment are royal images. They imply authority. They imply governance. They imply a Kingdom.

This is why I cannot accept the idea that Christianity is simply a nebulous spiritual movement. Jesus’ own actions point in the opposite direction. He gathered disciples, yes, but from among them He chose the Twelve. From among the Twelve, Peter receives a unique role. Then the apostolic mission continues through successors.

The apostles were not merely inspirational preachers.

They were the foundation stones of the renewed Israel.

The bishops are not merely religious administrators.

They are successors of the apostles.

The pope is not merely a religious CEO.

He is the successor of Peter, the chief steward of the Kingdom.




V. Peter, the Keys, and the Davidic Chief Steward

This is where Catholicism and Protestantism separate most clearly.

In Matthew 16, Jesus says to Peter:

“You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church.”

Then Jesus gives Peter the keys of the Kingdom and the authority to bind and loose.

Many Protestants interpret this differently. Some say the rock is Peter’s confession of faith. Some say Peter represents all believers. Some say the authority belongs only to the apostolic message. Catholics do not deny that Peter’s faith matters. Catholics do not deny that the apostles share authority. Catholics do not deny that the Church confesses Christ.

But Catholics insist that Peter personally receives a unique office.

The key is the keys.

In Isaiah 22, the Davidic king appoints a chief steward over the royal household. This steward receives the key of the house of David. He opens and no one shuts; he shuts and no one opens. This is not vague religious symbolism. It is royal household authority.

So when Jesus, the Son of David, gives Peter the keys of the Kingdom, Catholics see a direct biblical connection. Jesus is the King. Peter is the chief steward. The pope, as Peter’s successor, continues that office in history.

The pope does not replace Christ. He serves Christ.

The pope is not king. Christ is King.

The pope is not the source of truth. Christ is Truth.

The pope is not above Scripture. He is servant of the Word of God.

But if Jesus established a Kingdom and gave keys to Peter, then the papacy is not a medieval invention. It is the continuation of the Kingdom’s steward-office.

The Second Vatican Council’s Lumen Gentium teaches that the Roman Pontiff, as successor of Peter, is the perpetual and visible principle and foundation of unity for both the bishops and the faithful. The Vatican document The Primacy of the Successor of Peter explains the same point: the Petrine ministry exists to serve the unity of faith and communion.

That is why I remain Catholic.

If Christ founded a Kingdom, and if that Kingdom has keys, and if those keys belong to a steward-office, then the papacy is not an optional Catholic extra. It belongs to the architecture of the Kingdom.




VI. Mary as Queen Mother

The same Kingdom framework also explains Mary.

Many Protestants think Catholics exaggerate Mary because they assume Marian devotion competes with Christ. But in Catholic theology, Mary’s honor depends entirely on Christ’s kingship.

If Jesus is the Son of David, then Mary is the Mother of the King.

In the Davidic kingdom, the queen was often not the king’s wife but the king’s mother. The queen mother had an honored position in the royal court. She interceded. She represented the dignity of the kingdom. Her status came from her son.

Catholics honor Mary because Jesus is King.

Mary is not a goddess. She is not equal to Christ. She is not the source of grace. She is not the Savior.

She is the Mother of the King.

The Catechism teaches that Mary was exalted by the Lord as Queen over all things so that she might be more fully conformed to her Son. Her queenship is derivative, maternal, and Christ-centered.

This is why Catholic doctrine holds together. The papacy, the bishops, Mary, the sacraments, apostolic succession, and visible unity are not random Catholic inventions. They all flow from the same biblical vision:

Christianity is the fulfilled Kingdom of Israel.




VII. Bishops as Successors of the Apostles

If Jesus founded a visible Kingdom, then apostolic authority must continue after the apostles die. Otherwise, Christ created a visible apostolic structure for one generation only and then allowed it to disappear.

Catholicism teaches that bishops succeed the apostles.

This does not mean every bishop is personally holy. Obviously not. It does not mean every bishop is wise, courageous, or faithful in practice. History proves otherwise. But the weakness of the man does not erase the reality of the office.

The office matters because Christ established a Church that continues through history.

The bishops teach, sanctify, and govern. They preserve apostolic doctrine. They ordain priests and deacons. They shepherd local churches. Together with the pope, they maintain visible communion across the world.

This is why Catholic unity is not merely spiritual agreement. It is visible communion: unity in faith, sacraments, and apostolic government.

The Catechism teaches that the sole Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church, governed by the successor of Peter and the bishops in communion with him, while also recognizing that many elements of sanctification and truth exist outside her visible boundaries.

That last point matters.

Catholicism does not say Protestants have nothing. Catholicism says they have much: Scripture, baptism, prayer, faith in Christ, moral seriousness, preaching, love for God, and many elements of truth and sanctification.

But Catholicism also says they lack full visible communion with the apostolic structure Christ established.

That is the difference.




VIII. The Early Church Was Visible, Apostolic, and Hierarchical

The early Church does not look like modern non-denominational evangelicalism. It also does not look like a vague invisible movement.

It was visible. It had bishops, presbyters, deacons, sacraments, discipline, liturgy, and apostolic succession.

Clement of Rome, writing at the end of the first century, says the apostles appointed bishops and deacons and made provision for ministry to continue. His First Letter to the Corinthians shows concern for order, authority, and succession very early in Christian history.

Ignatius of Antioch, writing in the early second century, strongly emphasizes unity with the bishop. In his Letter to the Smyrnaeans, he says that where the bishop appears, there the people should be, just as where Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic Church.

Irenaeus of Lyons, writing in the second century, argues against heresy by appealing to apostolic succession, especially the succession of bishops in Rome. In Against Heresies, he points to the Church of Rome’s apostolic authority as a standard against false teaching.

This does not mean every later Catholic development was already fully expressed in the first century in the same language used today. Doctrine develops. Institutions develop. The Church grows as she reflects on the deposit of faith.

But development is not invention.

An acorn becomes an oak tree. It does not become a different species.

The Catholic Church developed because living things develop. The question is whether the development remains organically connected to what Christ and the apostles established. I believe it does.




IX. Why This Explains the Other Catholic-Protestant Differences

Once we understand this central disagreement, the other disagreements become easier to understand.

If the Church is primarily the invisible fellowship of true believers, then sola scriptura makes sense. Scripture becomes the final public authority because no visible Church office can claim universal binding authority.

But if the Church is the visible apostolic Kingdom Christ founded, then Scripture belongs within the living Tradition and teaching authority of that Church. The Bible is not less important in Catholicism. It is the inspired Word of God. But it was written, preserved, proclaimed, canonized, and interpreted within the Church.

If the Church is primarily invisible, then denominational division can be treated as unfortunate but not fatal. True believers remain spiritually one in Christ.

But if the Church is visible, then visible division is a wound against Christ’s intended unity.

If the Church is primarily invisible, then pastors and elders may be important for teaching and order.

But if the Church is the renewed Davidic Kingdom, then bishops in apostolic succession are not merely useful leaders. They belong to the Church’s constitution.

If Christianity is an invisible movement, then Catholic hierarchy looks like later human bureaucracy.

But if Christianity is the Kingdom of God in history, then Catholic hierarchy looks like biblical continuity.

That is why Catholic and Protestant debates often go in circles. We are not always arguing from the same map.

The Protestant map often says:

The Church is where true believers gather around the Gospel.

The Catholic map says:

The Church is the renewed Israel, visibly gathered into Christ’s Kingdom through apostles, sacraments, bishops, and communion with Peter.

Those are very different visions.






X. My Personal View

I do not write this because I hate Protestants. I do not.

Many Protestants love Jesus deeply. Many read Scripture more seriously than many Catholics. Many live lives of sincere prayer, repentance, sacrifice, and evangelization. Many put lukewarm Catholics to shame by their devotion.

I respect that.

But I cannot accept Protestant ecclesiology.

I cannot accept that Jesus founded something essentially invisible and that visible structure is secondary. I cannot accept that the Church can be reduced to wherever believers gather and preach the Gospel correctly. I cannot accept that apostolic authority disappeared into the Bible alone, leaving every generation to reconstruct Christianity by private interpretation.

For me, Christianity is not a nebulous spiritual movement.

It is a Kingdom.

It has a King.

It has a Queen Mother.

It has apostles seated on thrones.

It has a chief steward with keys.

It has bishops who succeed the apostles.

It has sacraments that communicate grace.

It has visible unity because the Incarnation itself is visible.

The invisible God became visible in Christ. So it makes sense that Christ’s Kingdom would have a visible body in history.

That body is the Catholic Church.




Conclusion: Jesus Built a Church, Not a Cloud

The difference between Catholics and Protestants is not just one doctrine among many. It is a difference over the nature of the Church itself.

Protestantism, in many of its forms, sees the Church primarily as the invisible communion of true believers, with visible churches serving as important communities of preaching, worship, discipline, and fellowship.

Catholicism sees the Church as both visible and spiritual, both human and divine, both hierarchical society and Mystical Body of Christ.

The Catholic Church is not merely a denomination. She is the renewed and fulfilled Davidic Kingdom of Israel: the Kingdom of God established by Jesus Christ and extended through history.

That is why Catholicism has a pope.
That is why Catholicism has bishops.
That is why Catholicism has sacraments.
That is why Catholicism honors Mary.
That is why Catholicism insists on visible unity.

These are not random traditions piled on top of the Gospel.

They are the architecture of the Kingdom.

Jesus did not merely inspire a movement.

He built His Church.

And if He built it, then I want to be inside what He built.




Select Sources and Further Reading




Tuesday, August 25, 2026

The Saint Agatha Skull Controversy




Catholic repsonse:


 

Bones, Relics, and the Saints: Is Catholic Veneration Pagan—or Ancient Christianity?

Why Catholics honor the relics of the saints, what the Bible actually says about holy remains, and how early Christian practice compares with Judaism and the pagan world.

A few days ago, a short video titled “Catholic paganism on display!” began circulating on YouTube, showing the relics of St. Agatha of Catania being publicly displayed during a Catholic celebration. Predictably, the clip sent some Protestant anti-Catholic commentators—and more than a few people with only the vaguest understanding of either Catholicism or ancient pagan religion—into a frenzy.

For them, the case was apparently closed at first glance: Catholics were displaying bones, therefore Catholicism must be pagan. Some went further, throwing around words such as idolatry, necromancy, cult, and evil, as though a few seconds of unfamiliar ritual were sufficient to settle nearly two thousand years of Christian history.

You can watch the video here: “Catholic paganism on display!” — YouTube , and a Catholic response video here: Yes, Mike Winger, This is Apostolic


There is a certain irony in confidently accusing an ancient Church of paganism while apparently knowing very little about either ancient Christianity or actual paganism.

Because here is the truth:

Yes, ancient Greeks and Romans honored the dead.

Yes, some pagan cultures preserved the remains of heroes, gathered at tombs, celebrated anniversaries, and believed that the presence of heroic remains could benefit a city or community.

And yes, later Christian devotion to saints sometimes developed external forms that can look surprisingly similar.

Catholics do not need to hide from that history.

But resemblance is not the same thing as identity, and similarity does not prove derivation.

More importantly, the Christian veneration of martyrs and their physical remains did not suddenly appear after Constantine supposedly corrupted Christianity with Roman paganism. We have explicit evidence of Christians preserving martyrs' bones, gathering at their resting places, celebrating their anniversaries, and carefully distinguishing the honor given to martyrs from the worship owed to Christ more than a century and a half before the Council of Nicaea.

And the roots go deeper still.

The Bible itself contains accounts of miracles associated with the bones of prophets and physical objects that had touched the apostles. First-century Judaism preserved human remains with great care. The earliest Christians inherited Jewish beliefs about the resurrection of the body while living inside a Greco-Roman culture already accustomed to tombs, memorials, hero cults, and public commemorations.

So if we are going to accuse Catholicism of paganism, we should at least do the historical homework first.

The real question is not whether a Catholic procession involving the bones of a saint looks strange to a twenty-first-century American Protestant.

The real question is:

What did the first Christians actually believe they were doing?

And when we examine the Bible, first-century Judaism, pagan Greek and Roman practices, and the writings of Christians who lived long before Constantine, the easy accusation of “Catholic paganism” begins to fall apart.


The St. Agatha Controversy

The immediate controversy concerned the August 2026 celebrations in Catania, Sicily, marking the 900th anniversary of the return of the relics of St. Agatha to the city in 1126.

Pope Leo XIV appointed Cardinal Pietro Parolin as his pontifical legate for the celebration. The relics were exposed for public veneration and were present for the pontifical Mass in Piazza Duomo.

(Holy See Press Office)

To someone unfamiliar with Catholic devotional culture, the sight can admittedly be startling.

There is a skull.

There are bones.

There are ornate reliquaries.

There is incense.

There are processions.

People may bow, kiss a reliquary, or touch devotional objects to it.

And that visual resemblance to certain ancient religious practices is precisely what critics seize upon.

But before shouting “pagan!”, we ought to ask what the Catholic Church actually teaches.


First: What Catholics Mean by “Veneration”

Before discussing bones, skulls, tombs, or paganism, we have to establish one distinction that is absolutely essential to Catholic theology.

Catholics are forbidden to worship saints.

The worship owed to God as God belongs to God alone.

The Catholic tradition normally distinguishes between adoration—traditionally called latria—which belongs to God alone, and veneration or honor given to God's saints.

The Catechism states that Christians are united with those who have died in Christ and that the saints continue to intercede for the Church. It quotes one of the earliest Christian martyr texts:

“We worship Christ as God's Son; we love the martyrs as the Lord's disciples and imitators.”

That sentence is especially important because it did not originate in medieval Catholicism. It comes from the Martyrdom of Polycarp, written in the second century. (vatican.va)

Catholic doctrine therefore does not claim:

“St. Agatha's bones are divine.”

It does not teach:

“This skull possesses magical power independent of God.”

Nor does it teach:

“We sacrifice to St. Agatha as a goddess.”

The Church instead understands the body of a saint as the former earthly temple of the Holy Spirit, destined for resurrection, and intimately connected with a person whom God sanctified.

The Vatican's 2017 instruction on relics explicitly warns that relics must be honored while avoiding superstition and illicit commerce. (press.vatican.va)

That qualification matters. Catholic theology itself recognizes that authentic devotion can be distorted into superstition.


What Exactly Is a Relic?

Traditionally Catholics speak of several kinds of relics.

A first-class relic is part of the saint's physical remains: bone, hair, blood, ashes, or another part of the body.

A second-class relic is something personally used or worn by the saint.

A contact relic, sometimes called a third-class relic in popular Catholic terminology, is an object that has been touched to a saint's remains or shrine.

The Church does not teach that these objects function like magical batteries.

The theological idea is instead deeply incarnational:

God works through material creation.

Christianity is, after all, built around some astonishingly material claims:

God became flesh.

Jesus healed with touch.

Christ used mud to heal a blind man's eyes.

Water is used in baptism.

Bread and wine become central to the Eucharistic mystery.

Oil is used for anointing.

Hands are laid upon people.

And, most importantly, Christians believe that the human body itself will someday be resurrected.

From that perspective, honoring the physical remains of a saint is not based upon hatred of the body but almost its opposite.

The body matters because God created it, sanctified it, and intends to raise it.


The Most Striking Biblical Example: The Bones of Elisha

If the Bible taught that nothing supernatural could ever occur in connection with the remains of a holy person, there would be one extraordinarily difficult passage to explain.

After the prophet Elisha died, Scripture tells us that another dead man was accidentally thrown into Elisha's grave:

“When the man touched the bones of Elisha, he revived and stood on his feet.”

— 2 Kings 13:21

(biblegateway.com)

This is about as literal an example of a holy man's bones being associated with a miracle as one could imagine.

Catholics should nevertheless avoid exaggerating the passage.

It does not say Israelites established a shrine and began praying to Elisha's bones.

It does not establish every later Catholic relic practice.

But it destroys the stronger claim sometimes made in polemics that the very idea of God's power operating in association with the remains of a holy person is necessarily pagan or unbiblical.

According to the biblical narrative, God himself performed a miracle when a corpse touched the bones of his prophet.


What About the New Testament?

The New Testament contains another practice remarkably close to what Catholics would later call contact relics.

Acts tells us:

“God did extraordinary miracles through Paul,”

to such a degree that handkerchiefs and aprons that had touched Paul's body were carried to the sick, and people were healed and delivered from evil spirits.

— Acts 19:11–12 (biblegateway.com)

Notice where Acts puts the power:

God did the miracles.

Paul's apron was not a magical talisman.

That is almost precisely the distinction Catholic theology makes concerning relics.

Something connected physically with a holy person becomes an occasion through which God, not the object itself, acts.

Acts 5:15 contains a related tradition concerning people hoping that even Peter's shadow might fall upon the sick.

Once again, this does not prove every Catholic custom that developed centuries later.

It does demonstrate, however, that biblical Christianity was not uncomfortable with the idea that God's grace could be manifested through bodily contact and material things connected with the apostles.


And Then There Is Joseph's Body

The Old Testament also shows remarkable reverence for the physical remains of the righteous.

Joseph, dying in Egypt, commanded the Israelites eventually to carry his bones back to the Promised Land.

Exodus records that Moses did precisely that.

The bones of Joseph therefore accompanied Israel during the Exodus.

Again, they were not worshiped.

But neither were they dismissed as a meaningless shell that could simply be discarded.

The physical remains of a holy ancestor mattered because they were connected with the identity, covenant, and memory of God's people.


But Didn't Judaism Consider Corpses Unclean?

Yes.

And this is one of the strongest arguments that must be considered when discussing the Jewish background.

According to Numbers 19, touching a dead body rendered an Israelite ceremonially unclean.

That is important because it demonstrates that ancient Israel did not possess an uncomplicated “relic cult” corresponding directly to later Catholic practice.

Jewish attitudes toward human remains combined profound reverence for the dead with ritual restrictions concerning corpse impurity.

Yet ceremonial impurity did not mean that dead bodies were evil.

Jews buried their dead carefully and preserved their remains.

Indeed, archaeology gives us striking evidence from the period immediately surrounding the life of Jesus.

During the late Second Temple period, especially around Jerusalem, Jewish families sometimes practiced secondary burial. After decomposition, the bones of the deceased could be gathered and placed in stone boxes called ossuaries.

The Metropolitan Museum of Art notes that this practice flourished around Jerusalem from approximately the late first century BC through the first century AD. (resources.metmuseum.org)

The famous Caiaphas ossuary provides another archaeological example from this cultural world. (imj.org.il)

Thus the first Christians arose within a Jewish culture that simultaneously:

  • respected and preserved human remains,

  • maintained family tombs,

  • sometimes gathered bones after decomposition,

  • remembered righteous ancestors,

  • regarded corpse contact as ritually defiling,

  • and possessed Scripture containing the extraordinary miracle involving Elisha's bones.

That is a much more complex background than simply saying, “Jews wanted nothing to do with bones.”


Jewish Prayer for the Dead

Catholic Bibles also contain 2 Maccabees 12, where Judas Maccabeus makes provision for an offering on behalf of fallen Jewish soldiers.

Catholics traditionally cite this passage primarily in relation to prayer for the dead and purgatory.

Protestants do not generally accept 2 Maccabees as canonical Scripture, so it cannot by itself settle a Catholic-Protestant debate.

Historically, however, it remains extremely important.

Whether one regards the book as inspired Scripture or merely ancient Jewish literature, it proves that pre-Christian Jews could engage in religious acts on behalf of the dead.

Christian concern for departed believers therefore cannot simply be attributed to the conversion of pagan Romans centuries later.


The Crucial Pre-Nicene Evidence: St. Polycarp

Now we reach perhaps the most important historical evidence of all.

The Council of Nicaea occurred in AD 325.

Some critics of Catholicism argue that practices such as venerating martyrs and their relics appeared only after Constantine supposedly paganized Christianity.

The historical record makes that theory extraordinarily difficult to sustain.

Consider St. Polycarp of Smyrna.

Polycarp was an early Christian bishop traditionally connected with the apostolic generation. He was executed in the second century, probably around AD 155–156.

Shortly after his martyrdom, the Christians of Smyrna wrote an account describing what happened to his body.

They specifically denied that honoring Polycarp meant replacing Christ with Polycarp.

The text says:

“We worship Him who is the Son of God, but the martyrs…we love.”

Then comes the remarkable description of Polycarp's remains.

After his body had been burned, the Christians gathered his bones, describing them as more valuable than precious stones, and deposited them in a suitable place.

They then explained why.

They hoped to gather there again to celebrate the anniversary of his martyrdom, both to remember previous martyrs and to prepare Christians for similar faithfulness.

(newadvent.org)

Consider what we have here.

This is roughly 170 years before Nicaea.

It contains:

the preservation of a martyr's bones;

special honor given to those bones;

a designated place where they were kept;

Christians assembling there;

and

an annual liturgical commemoration of the martyr.

It is difficult to maintain that Christian reverence for martyrs' remains originated with Constantine when we possess this evidence from the second century.


Tertullian: Christian Memorials Before Nicaea

Around the beginning of the third century, the North African Christian writer Tertullian described several Christian customs that he believed were preserved through tradition.

Among them he mentions annual offerings made for the dead on their anniversaries. (newadvent.org)

This does not prove every later practice involving saints' relics.

But it confirms something important:

Christians were already maintaining liturgical commemorations of departed believers well before Constantine.

Even more interestingly, Tertullian was fiercely opposed to pagan religion.

He condemned idolatrous funeral rites and pagan religious spectacles. (newadvent.org)

This matters because it demonstrates that early Christians were not simply unaware that pagan society also honored the dead.

They knew it.

They rejected what they understood to be pagan worship.

Yet they continued their own Christian commemorations of the departed.


St. Cyprian: Keep Track of the Martyrs' Death Days

An even clearer witness comes from St. Cyprian of Carthage, who died as a martyr in AD 258.

Writing during persecution, Cyprian instructed Christians to record the dates on which imprisoned believers died:

“take note of their days on which they depart”

so that their commemorations could be celebrated among the memorials of the martyrs.

He also refers to offerings and Eucharistic celebrations connected with those commemorations. (newadvent.org)

Again:

AD 258.

That is approximately 67 years before Nicaea.

There was already a recognizable Christian calendar of martyr commemorations.


Peter and Paul: Visiting the Apostolic Memorials Around AD 200

Another fascinating piece of evidence comes from a Roman Christian named Gaius, or Caius, writing around AD 200.

His words survive because the fourth-century historian Eusebius quoted them.

Gaius challenged an opponent:

“I can show the trophies of the apostles.”

He then directed him to the Vatican and the Ostian Way, where memorials associated with Peter and Paul could be found. (newadvent.org)

Exactly what tropaia—“trophies”—meant in every architectural detail is debated.

But the evidence demonstrates that around AD 200 Christians in Rome identified specific physical locations associated with the deaths or burials of Peter and Paul.

The modern excavations beneath St. Peter's Basilica have made this testimony even more historically interesting.

Whatever conclusions one reaches concerning particular bones attributed to Peter, devotion centered upon Peter's Vatican burial site is not a medieval invention.

Its roots reach far back into pre-Constantinian Christianity. (osservatoreromano.va)


So Was the Entire Modern Catholic Relic System Already Present in AD 150?

No.

And Catholics should be willing to say so.

Historical development is real.

The Christians who gathered Polycarp's bones were not operating a medieval reliquary treasury.

The enormous translation of relics between cities, subdivision of relics, elaborate reliquaries, relic pilgrimages spanning continents, and some of the miraculous traditions associated with relics became much more prominent during late antiquity and the Middle Ages.

Historian Robert Wiśniewski, in his major Oxford study The Beginnings of the Cult of Relics, emphasizes precisely this development. Practices involving touching, moving, discovering, distributing, and attributing protective functions to relics expanded substantially during late antiquity. (academic.oup.com)

That does not mean there was no earlier foundation.

Rather, the evidence suggests a progression:

memory of martyrs → honor at their graves → preservation of their remains → liturgical anniversaries → pilgrimage and shrine culture → broader circulation and division of relics.

Development is not the same thing as invention.

The Eucharistic liturgy itself developed in its ceremonial forms.

Church architecture developed.

The biblical canon was formally clarified over time.

Christian vocabulary concerning the Trinity developed.

The relevant question is therefore not:

“Did third-century Christians use a seventeenth-century reliquary?”

Obviously they did not.

The better question is:

Can we see the theological and devotional roots of relic veneration before Constantine?

The answer is clearly yes.


But What About the Pagans?

This is where Catholics should resist overly simplistic apologetics.

Ancient Greeks absolutely did honor deceased heroes at tombs.

Greek hero cults existed centuries before Christianity.

Heroes—sometimes mythological, sometimes believed to have been historical—could receive ritual honor after death.

Their tombs could become religious centers.

Offerings could be made.

Annual commemorations could occur.

Communities sometimes believed possession of a hero's remains brought protection or prestige.

Archaeological and classical scholarship has documented the importance of tomb cult and hero cult throughout ancient Greece. (journals.uchicago.edu)

There are therefore undeniable outward similarities with later Christian saint devotion.

They can include:

a revered dead person;

a tomb or shrine;

annual commemorations;

pilgrimage;

physical remains;

the belief that a deceased holy or heroic figure remained somehow relevant to the community.

To say that there is “absolutely no resemblance whatsoever” would not be historically serious.


Did Greeks Actually Value Heroes' Bones?

Yes.

Ancient traditions even tell stories about cities acquiring the bones of heroes.

The alleged remains of figures such as Orestes and Theseus could become politically and religiously important.

A hero's tomb could function as a focal point for civic identity and supernatural protection.

This helps explain why a modern observer familiar with classical religion might look at a Christian procession carrying a saint's bones and say:

“That looks like Greek hero cult.”

At the level of outward religious behavior, sometimes it does.

The real dispute concerns why Christians did it and what they believed they were doing.


Does Similarity Prove Borrowing?

No.

Similarity establishes a question, not an answer.

Human beings across radically different cultures bury honored leaders, preserve ancestral remains, build memorials, visit graves, celebrate anniversaries, and keep objects associated with beloved people.

The United States preserves the clothing, furniture, letters, houses, and burial places of famous Americans without believing that Abraham Lincoln is a god.

Families preserve wedding rings and photographs.

People visit Arlington National Cemetery.

We build monuments over the graves of soldiers.

None of those examples is identical to Catholic relic veneration, but they demonstrate an important principle:

similar external actions do not necessarily possess identical theological meanings.

The same is true in antiquity.

A pagan might burn incense before an emperor because he believed the emperor possessed divine status.

A Christian might burn incense near the tomb of a martyr while believing that the martyr was a creature entirely dependent upon the one God.

The physical gesture alone cannot tell us the theology behind it.


Could Christianity Have Adopted Some Cultural Forms From Pagan Society?

Here the historically responsible answer is:

Quite possibly.

Christianity did not develop in a cultural vacuum.

Greek-speaking and Latin-speaking Christians lived inside the Greco-Roman world.

They spoke Greek and Latin.

They used Roman roads.

They adopted architectural forms.

They used philosophical terminology.

They participated in ordinary funeral customs.

It would therefore be surprising if Christian modes of commemorating their dead showed absolutely no influence from surrounding cultures.

Even older Catholic scholarship sometimes acknowledged possible parallels between Christian martyr anniversaries and Greco-Roman commemorations of the dead. (newadvent.org)

Modern scholarship likewise studies the interaction between Christian relic practices and the broader religious culture of late antiquity.

But interaction does not necessarily mean wholesale derivation.

Wiśniewski, for example, finds meaningful interaction between Christian and non-Christian practices while cautioning against simply explaining Christian beliefs as direct copies of pagan ones. (academic.oup.com)

That is probably the most historically balanced position.

Christianity inherited ideas from Judaism, developed beliefs grounded in Christ and resurrection theology, and expressed those beliefs within a Greco-Roman cultural environment.

All three factors matter.


Christianity Itself Admits That Paganism Influenced Certain Customs

Catholics do not need to believe that every external Christian custom dropped directly from heaven.

The Church has often Christianized cultural practices.

Dates, architectural forms, artistic styles, processions, philosophical vocabulary, and local customs can be adopted and given a new meaning.

The theological question is not simply:

“Did pagans ever do something that looked like this?”

If that were the standard, Christians could hardly light candles, sing hymns, use incense, build temples or churches, hold religious processions, kneel, sacrifice money, wear religious clothing, celebrate feast days, or bury their dead ceremonially—because pagan religions did all of those things.

The real question is:

Does Christianity preserve the pagan theology behind the practice?

In the case of saints, Catholicism says no.


The Resurrection Changes Everything

One of the deepest differences between Christian relic theology and much of classical pagan religion is the Christian doctrine of the resurrection of the body.

A saint's body is not regarded merely as the abandoned shell of a soul.

St. Paul teaches that the body will be raised.

Christian baptism sanctifies the body.

The Eucharist is received bodily.

The Holy Spirit dwells in Christians.

Martyrs surrendered their bodies to torture rather than deny Christ.

Their bones consequently became physical testimony to their confession of faith.

The Vatican's current instruction explains relic veneration in precisely this resurrection-centered way: the body of a saint was a temple of the Holy Spirit and is destined for resurrection. (vatican.va)

That is distinctly Christian theology.


Why Are Relics Connected With Catholic Altars?

The relationship between relics and Mass is particularly significant.

The present General Instruction of the Roman Missal says:

“The practice of placing relics of Saints, even those not Martyrs, under the altar to be dedicated is fittingly retained.”

The Church also permits relics of saints exposed for public veneration to be incensed at the beginning of Mass. (vatican.va)

Why?

The symbolism ultimately connects the sacrifice of the martyrs with the sacrifice of Christ.

The martyrs did not replace Jesus.

They died because of Jesus.

Their death was understood as participation in his victory.

This is already visible in the Martyrdom of Polycarp, whose author carefully insists that Christ alone is worshiped while the martyrs are loved as disciples of Christ.

Thus placing a martyr's relic near an altar does not mean:

“We sacrifice to this dead saint.”

It means almost exactly the opposite:

This Christian gave everything because he or she believed in the sacrifice being celebrated here.


Is Talking to Saints Necromancy?

This accusation deserves separate treatment.

The Bible clearly condemns necromancy.

Israel was forbidden to attempt to conjure the dead in order to obtain secret knowledge or supernatural power.

The classic example is Saul consulting the medium at Endor.

Catholicism accepts those prohibitions.

But asking a saint to pray is theologically different from attempting to summon a spirit.

Catholics do not attempt to cause St. Peter, St. Agatha, or Mary to materialize.

They do not ask saints to reveal tomorrow's lottery numbers.

They do not attempt to control spirits through occult rituals.

They ask:

“Pray for us.”

The underlying Catholic argument is that Christians who die in Christ remain members of Christ's body.

The Catechism summarizes this as the communion of saints, teaching that death does not destroy the communion existing among Christians. (vatican.va)

Whether Scripture proves that Christians should directly invoke saints is a legitimate Catholic-Protestant debate.

But simply labeling the practice “necromancy” assumes the very thing being debated.


What About “There Is One Mediator Between God and Man”?

Protestants frequently cite 1 Timothy 2:5:

“There is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus.”

Catholics believe that verse completely.

Christ is the unique mediator of salvation.

No saint died to redeem humanity.

No saint reconciles humanity to the Father independently of Christ.

But immediately before Paul's declaration about the one mediator, he urges Christians to offer “supplications, prayers, intercessions” for everyone.

Human intercession therefore does not compete with Christ's unique mediation.

When I ask another Christian:

“Please pray for me,”

I have not created another redeemer.

Catholic theology applies the same principle to Christians who are already with Christ.

A Protestant may reasonably respond that Scripture never explicitly commands Christians on earth to address departed saints.

That is a genuine point of disagreement.

But it is a different argument from claiming that Catholics believe Mary or the saints replace Christ.

They do not.


The Strongest Protestant Objection

A thoughtful Protestant critique does not need to pretend that Polycarp never existed or that 2 Kings never mentions Elisha's bones.

A stronger objection would be:

Yes, Scripture contains miraculous contact with sacred persons and objects, and yes, early Christians honored martyrs. But those isolated examples do not authorize the elaborate invocation, kissing, incensing, procession, subdivision, and public display of human relics found in later Catholicism.

That objection deserves to be taken seriously.

There is a genuine historical development between the New Testament period and medieval Catholic relic culture.

There were also abuses.

Relics were sometimes fraudulently identified.

Commercialization occurred.

Superstitious ideas sometimes attached themselves to particular shrines.

Even Catholic authorities have repeatedly attempted to regulate such abuses.

Canon law today absolutely forbids the sale of sacred relics, and Vatican regulations require ecclesiastical authentication before relics are exposed for public veneration. (vatican.va)

Catholics therefore do not need to defend every relic ever advertised in Christian history.

Authenticity is a historical question.

Proper veneration is a theological question.

Abuse is a pastoral question.

They should not be confused.


The Strongest Catholic Response

The Catholic answer is cumulative rather than dependent upon one proof text.

Catholics see a biblical and historical pattern:

Joseph's bones are preserved and carried with Israel.

Elisha's bones become the occasion of a resurrection miracle.

Objects touching Paul's body become instruments through which God heals.

The earliest Christians carefully preserve the remains of their martyrs.

Second-century Christians gather around Polycarp's remains and commemorate his martyrdom.

By around AD 200 Christians identify memorials associated with Peter and Paul in Rome.

Tertullian describes annual Christian commemorations of the departed.

Cyprian records annual Eucharistic commemorations of martyrs before AD 258.

All of this predates Constantine and Nicaea.

Consequently, the theory that Constantine or the fourth-century Roman state simply imported pagan hero worship into Christianity cannot explain the evidence.

The chronology is wrong.


Were the Early Christians Secretly Reintroducing Paganism?

There is another difficulty with that theory.

The Christians who preserved Polycarp's bones were themselves persecuted by pagan authorities.

They were not attempting to make Christianity more acceptable to Roman religion.

And their document explicitly distinguishes Christian devotion from worship:

Christ is worshiped; martyrs are loved and honored.

Likewise, writers such as Tertullian were ferocious critics of pagan idolatry.

Early Christians were quite capable of recognizing pagan religious practices and rejecting them.

It is therefore historically implausible to assume that whenever a Christian practice resembles a pagan one, early Christians must simply have forgotten their opposition to pagan worship.

More likely, Christians took universal human behaviors—burying the dead, honoring heroes, keeping anniversaries, visiting tombs—and interpreted them through a radically different theological framework:

Christ's Resurrection.


But Pagans Really Did Have Hero Cults

None of that requires Catholics to deny the resemblance.

Greek religion provides perhaps the strongest parallel.

Scholars describe hero cult as organized religious honor directed toward extraordinary deceased figures, often centered upon a tomb or sacred location. (journals.uchicago.edu)

A city's possession of a hero's remains could acquire civic importance.

Later Christian cities could similarly identify themselves with patron saints and their relics.

That parallel is real.

A historian is entirely justified in investigating whether pagan forms influenced Christian expression.

Where the argument becomes too simplistic is when resemblance is treated as proof of theological identity.

A Christian praying near St. Peter's tomb and an Athenian making sacrifice to a hero may occupy superficially comparable sacred spaces while believing fundamentally different things about God, death, sacrifice, resurrection, and the person being honored.


Christianity Was Neither Purely Jewish nor Secretly Pagan

Perhaps the most accurate historical picture is that Christianity emerged from Judaism within the Greco-Roman world.

That means both backgrounds matter.

From Judaism Christianity inherited:

the God of Abraham;

the Hebrew Scriptures;

prophets and patriarchs;

reverence for the righteous dead;

the carrying of Joseph's bones;

the miraculous story of Elisha's bones;

Jewish burial traditions;

and belief in bodily resurrection, especially within certain Jewish movements.

From its Greco-Roman environment Christianity encountered:

hero cults;

memorial festivals;

processions;

incense;

shrines;

funerary associations;

pilgrimages;

and elaborate ways of honoring distinguished dead persons.

Christianity then reorganized these things around its central proclamation:

Jesus Christ has risen from the dead.

The saint was not another god.

The saint was evidence of what Christ could do to a human being.

The martyr's tomb was not the grave of a demigod.

It was the resting place of someone awaiting resurrection.


Why Bones?

This brings us back to the disturbing image of a human skull.

Why not simply remember the saint spiritually?

Because Christianity does not teach salvation from the body.

It teaches salvation of the body.

The bones of St. Agatha are disturbing precisely because death is disturbing.

They confront us with mortality.

Catholicism does something modern Western culture often avoids: it places death visibly before us.

A skull says:

Agatha died.

Christian faith adds:

Agatha will rise.

In this sense a relic is almost an anti-death symbol.

Its message is not:

“Look at the power of death.”

Its message is:

“Death did not get the final word.”


And That Is What Was Happening in Catania

The Vatican's own description of the 2026 celebrations makes this theology clear.

Pope Leo XIV described St. Agatha's martyrdom as a manifestation of the victory of grace over violence, faith over fear, and charity over death. (press.vatican.va)

Cardinal Parolin similarly emphasized that Agatha's significance came from her communion with Christ. (vaticannews.va)

One can certainly dislike the visual presentation.

One can find the display of a skull culturally jarring.

A Catholic can even wonder whether a particular devotional ceremony communicates Christian theology effectively to modern observers.

Those are fair questions.

But none of them proves pagan worship.


My Catholic Conclusion

As a Catholic, I believe the historic Christian practice of venerating saints and their relics is defensible from Scripture, Tradition, and the theology of the Resurrection.

But I also think Catholics weaken their argument when we pretend there are no parallels with pagan religion or that every later relic custom existed unchanged in the first century.

They did not.

There were Greek and Roman hero cults.

There were ancient religious practices centered upon tombs and heroic remains.

Christian relic devotion did develop over time.

Some cultural borrowing or adaptation is entirely plausible.

And abuses unquestionably occurred.

None of that establishes that the theology itself is pagan.

The decisive evidence is that reverence for Christian martyrs and their bodily remains appears long before Constantine, while the Church was still persecuted and while Christian writers explicitly rejected pagan worship.

The Christians of Smyrna did not believe Polycarp was another god.

They said precisely the opposite.

They worshiped Christ.

They loved Polycarp because he belonged to Christ.

And then they gathered his bones.

That was roughly AD 155.

Nicaea would not meet for another 170 years.

So when someone points to the bones of St. Agatha and announces:

“This proves Catholicism is pagan,”

the historically responsible response is not to become defensive.

It is to ask:

Have we actually examined the Bible, Judaism, Greek and Roman religion, and the writings of the Christians who lived before Constantine?

Once we do, the picture becomes considerably more complicated.

Catholic devotion to relics certainly developed within the ancient Mediterranean world, and some of its external forms resemble practices that existed before Christianity.

But its theological foundation—Christ's incarnation, the sanctification of the human body, the communion of saints, martyrdom, and the resurrection of the flesh—is unmistakably Christian.

The bones are not God.

The saint is not God.

The reliquary is not God.

God alone is worshiped.

The relic simply points beyond itself to what Catholics believe God has already accomplished in one of His children—and what He promises eventually to accomplish in all who belong to Christ:

“I believe in the resurrection of the body and life everlasting.”

That is ultimately why Catholics keep the bones.


Sources and Further Reading

The 2026 St. Agatha controversy and celebration

YouTube — “Catholic paganism on display!”
Watch the short

Holy See Press Office — Letter of Pope Leo XIV concerning the ninth centenary of the return of St. Agatha's relics to Catania
Read the Vatican document

Vatican News — “Cardinal Parolin in Sicily: Saint Agatha's witness still speaks to the Church”
Read Vatican News

Archdiocese of Catania — official diocesan coverage and schedule of the Agatha Jubilee celebrations
Visit the Archdiocese of Catania

For an example of the hostile interpretation circulating online, see the article describing the ceremony as “necromancy.” Its language is polemical, but it is useful for understanding the criticism being answered here. (disntr.com)

Scripture

2 Kings 13:21 — the miracle associated with Elisha's bones
Read 2 Kings 13:21

Acts 19:11–12 — objects touching Paul's body carried to the sick
Read Acts 19:11–12

Pre-Nicene Christianity

The Martyrdom of Polycarp, especially chapters 17–18 — one of the clearest second-century witnesses to the distinction between worship of Christ and honor shown to martyrs, as well as the preservation of Polycarp's bones.
Read the Martyrdom of Polycarp

Eusebius, Church History, Book IV — preserves the Polycarp account and its explicit distinction between worship of Christ and love of the martyrs.
Read Eusebius, Book IV

Tertullian, De Corona, chapter 3 — refers to annual Christian offerings and commemorations for the dead.
Read Tertullian's De Corona

St. Cyprian of Carthage, Epistle 36 — instructs Christians to record martyrs' death dates for liturgical commemoration.
Read Cyprian, Epistle 36

Gaius of Rome, Fragments — the approximately AD 200 reference to the “trophies” of Peter and Paul at the Vatican and Ostian Road.
Read the surviving fragments of Gaius

Eusebius, Church History, Book II, chapter 25 — preserves Gaius's testimony concerning Peter and Paul.
Read Eusebius, Book II

Catholic doctrine and present Church discipline

Catechism of the Catholic Church §§954–962 — Communion of Saints
Read the Catechism on the Communion of Saints

Catechism §§1674–1676 — relics and popular piety
Read the Catechism on relics and popular devotion

General Instruction of the Roman Missal §§277, 302 — relics at Mass and beneath altars
Read the General Instruction of the Roman Missal

Congregation for the Causes of Saints — Relics in the Church: Authenticity and Preservation (2017)
Read the Vatican instruction on relics

Code of Canon Law, Canons 1186–1190 — governing saints, sacred images, relics, and prohibiting the sale of relics.
Read Canons 1186–1190

First-century Judaism and archaeology

Metropolitan Museum of Art — First-century Judean ossuary and the practice of secondary bone burial
View the Met's Judean ossuary

Israel Museum — Ossuary of Caiaphas
View the Caiaphas ossuary

Greek hero cult and pagan parallels

Carla M. Antonaccio, “Contesting the Past: Hero Cult, Tomb Cult, and Epic in Early Greece,” American Journal of Archaeology — scholarly discussion of Greek hero and tomb cult. (journals.uchicago.edu)

Gunnel Ekroth, “Heroes—Living or Dead?” in The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Greek Religion — overview of Greek hero cults, cult locations, and ritual practices.
View the Oxford Academic entry

Robert WiÅ›niewski, The Beginnings of the Cult of Relics, Oxford University Press — especially valuable because it treats Christian relic practices historically rather than assuming either complete pagan derivation or complete cultural isolation.
Explore The Beginnings of the Cult of Relics

Robert WiÅ›niewski, “Touching Relics” — discussion of how physical contact with saints' remains developed within early Christianity.
Read the Oxford chapter overview

Catechism Q&A — The Catholic Answer in One Sentence

Q: Why do Catholics venerate the relics and bones of saints if worship belongs to God alone?

A: Catholics do not worship relics or saints; they honor the bodily remains of holy men and women as members of Christ, temples of the Holy Spirit, and future participants in the resurrection, while giving adoration to God alone.** (Catechism of the Catholic Church §§956–957, 1674)



Tuesday, June 30, 2026

The Bad Popes: How Can I Be Catholic When Some Popes Were So Terrible?

 



The Bad Popes: How Can I Be Catholic When Some Popes Were So Terrible?

I love the Catholic Church. I believe she is the Church founded by Jesus Christ. I believe in the Eucharist, the sacraments, apostolic succession, the communion of saints, Sacred Scripture, Sacred Tradition, and the authority Christ gave to Peter and the apostles.

But I will be honest: the history of the “bad popes” bothers me.

It should bother us.

There have been popes who were saints, martyrs, reformers, theologians, missionaries, defenders of the poor, and courageous shepherds of souls. But there have also been popes who were worldly, corrupt, politically ruthless, immoral, negligent, or simply unworthy of the office they held. Some were not just “imperfect.” Some were scandalous.

As a Catholic, I do not think we help the Church by pretending otherwise.

The question is not, “Were there bad popes?” Yes, there were. The real question is: does the sinfulness of some popes disprove Catholicism?

I do not believe it does.

But I also do not believe Catholics should respond with denial, defensiveness, or blind loyalty to men who disgraced the office of Peter. The Catholic answer is not that every pope was holy. The Catholic answer is that Christ is holy, even when His ministers are not.

The Catholic Faith Is Not Built on the Personal Holiness of Every Pope

One of the biggest misunderstandings about Catholicism is the idea that Catholics believe the pope is perfect. We do not.

Catholics do not believe the pope is sinless. We do not believe every pope is automatically a saint. We do not believe every papal decision is wise. We do not believe every political opinion, administrative choice, appointment, personal action, or offhand comment of a pope is protected by the Holy Spirit.

Papal infallibility is much narrower than many critics realize. Vatican I taught that the pope is protected from error when, as supreme pastor and teacher of all Christians, he definitively defines a doctrine of faith or morals to be held by the whole Church. Vatican I also made clear that the Holy Spirit was not promised to Peter’s successors so they could invent new doctrine, but so they could guard and faithfully explain the apostolic deposit of faith.

That is very different from saying a pope cannot be corrupt, cowardly, foolish, immoral, political, vain, or personally sinful.

The Catechism says the visible bonds of unity in the Church include one faith received from the apostles, common worship and sacraments, and apostolic succession through Holy Orders. It also teaches that the Church of Christ “subsists in the Catholic Church,” governed by the successor of Peter and the bishops in communion with him, while also acknowledging that many elements of sanctification and truth exist outside her visible confines.

That means a Catholic does not have to defend evil. We defend the faith. We defend the sacraments. We defend the apostolic office. We defend Christ’s promise to His Church.

But we do not have to defend corruption.

The First “Bad Pope” Problem Was Peter Himself

This may sound shocking, but the problem of sinful Church leadership begins in the New Testament.

St. Peter was chosen by Christ. Jesus said to him, “You are Peter,” and gave him the keys of the Kingdom of Heaven. Catholics see this as foundational for the office of Peter and the papacy.

But Peter was not personally flawless.

Peter confessed Jesus as the Christ, but he also misunderstood Christ’s mission. He denied Jesus three times. He needed mercy. He needed restoration. In John 21, Christ did not restore Peter by pretending Peter had never fallen. He restored him by commanding him to feed His sheep.

Even after Pentecost, Peter could still be wrong in conduct. St. Paul says he opposed Cephas, meaning Peter, “to his face” because Peter’s behavior toward Gentile Christians was wrong. That passage matters because it shows that recognizing Peter’s authority does not mean pretending Peter can never be criticized.

So from the very beginning, Catholicism has never depended on the idea that Church leaders are personally sinless. The office is real. The grace is real. The authority is real.

But the man can still be weak.

The Church Is a Visible Kingdom, Not an Invisible Idea

This is also why I cannot accept the idea that Jesus came merely to reform first-century Judaism, or to start some vague, invisible, spiritual association of individual believers with no visible authority, no visible structure, and no visible family.

I believe Jesus came as the Messiah of Israel. He came not to abolish God’s promises, but to fulfill them. He came to restore, fulfill, and universalize the Kingdom of David — not as a temporary political kingdom limited to one nation, but as the Kingdom of God, open to all nations, with Christ Himself as King.

The angel Gabriel says this plainly at the Annunciation. Jesus would receive “the throne of David his father,” reign over the house of Jacob forever, and of His Kingdom there would be no end. That is royal, Davidic, kingdom language. It is not merely private spirituality. It is not merely an invisible religious feeling. It is a Kingdom.

This is one reason Catholics see such importance in Matthew 16. Jesus gives Peter “the keys to the Kingdom of heaven.” In Isaiah 22, the key of the House of David is associated with authority in the royal household. Catholics therefore see a typological connection: Peter is not a replacement for Christ, but the visible steward of Christ the King’s household. The Pope is not the true King. Christ is. But the Pope serves as the visible steward, servant, and vicar of the King.

This also helps explain Catholic devotion to Mary. If Jesus is the Davidic King, then Mary is not just another believer. She is the Mother of the King. In the Davidic kingdom, the queen mother held a special place. Catholic belief that Mary is Queen does not take glory away from Christ; it flows from who Christ is. The Catechism teaches that Mary was exalted by the Lord as “Queen over all things,” and Revelation 12 presents the image of a crowned woman associated with the birth of the Messiah.

The bishops, too, are not merely religious managers or motivational speakers. They are successors of the apostles. The Catechism teaches that Christ governs His Church through Peter and the other apostles, who are present in their successors: the Pope and the college of bishops.

I know some Christians disagree with this Catholic reading. I want to be fair about that. Many Protestants sincerely believe the Church is fundamentally the invisible fellowship of all true believers. Catholics also believe that God knows His own and that grace can work beyond visible Catholic boundaries. But Catholicism insists that the Church is not invisible only. She is visible, sacramental, historical, institutional, familial, and apostolic.

Vatican II teaches that the Church is “constituted and organized in the world as a society,” and that this visible social structure serves the Spirit of Christ in building up the Body of Christ. It also teaches that the Roman Pontiff is the “perpetual and visible principle and foundation of unity” of both bishops and faithful, while each bishop is a visible principle of unity in his own particular church.

And this is where the scandal of bad popes becomes painful, but understandable.

If the Church is a visible Kingdom, a visible family, a visible Body, and a visible household, then she will have visible leaders. And because those leaders are men, they will sometimes be sinful men. Some will be weak. Some will be foolish. Some will be worldly. Some, tragically, will be corrupt.

A visible Church will have visible wounds.

But that does not disprove the Church. In a strange way, it proves exactly what Catholicism teaches about the Church on earth: she is holy because Christ is holy, but she is also made up of sinners who constantly need purification, repentance, and reform.

This is why anti-Catholic arguments often miss the point. They act as if Catholics believe our hope is in the Pope, or in bishops, or in priests, or in any man. We do not. We respect the offices Christ established. We believe authority matters. We believe apostolic succession matters. We believe the Pope and bishops have real responsibilities in the household of God.

But our hope is not in them.

Our hope is in Jesus Christ.

The Pope is not the head of the Church in the ultimate sense. Christ is. The bishops are not the source of grace. Christ is. Priests do not save us by their own power. Christ saves. The Church’s leaders matter because Christ chose to work through visible instruments, but those instruments remain human, fragile, and accountable to God.

So when I see bad popes in history, I do not have to pretend they were good. I can say they were bad. I can say they sinned. I can say they wounded the Church. But I do not have to conclude that Christ abandoned His Church.

A bad steward does not mean there is no King.

A corrupt servant does not mean there is no Master.

A sinful pope does not mean there is no Christ.

It means the Church, like Israel before her, is a divine mystery carried in human hands. And sometimes those hands are dirty.

So How Bad Were the Bad Popes?

Some were very bad.

Pope Stephen VI is remembered for one of the strangest and most disturbing episodes in Church history: the Cadaver Synod. In 897, the corpse of Pope Formosus was exhumed, placed on trial, stripped of papal vestments, mutilated, and thrown into the Tiber River. Later, the Church reversed the actions against Formosus and recognized the validity of his ordinations.

Pope John XII, who reigned in the tenth century, is often listed among the most immoral popes. The Catholic Encyclopedia describes him as a “coarse, immoral man” and says the Lateran was spoken of as a brothel under him. That is not an anti-Catholic source saying this. That is a Catholic source acknowledging a shameful reality.

Pope Benedict IX was another disgraceful figure. The Catholic Encyclopedia bluntly calls him “a disgrace to the Chair of Peter.” He came from a powerful Roman family, treated the papacy almost like a family possession, and was involved in one of the most chaotic periods in papal history.

Pope Alexander VI, Rodrigo Borgia, is perhaps the most infamous Renaissance pope. His name became associated with nepotism, political intrigue, and sexual immorality. Catholic sources acknowledge the scandals surrounding his children and his family favoritism, while historians also recognize that some stories about the Borgias were exaggerated by enemies and later legend.

Pope Leo X was not necessarily “evil” in the same dramatic way as some others, but his worldliness and financial mismanagement helped set the stage for the Protestant Reformation. The Catholic Encyclopedia says jubilees and indulgences were degraded almost entirely into financial transactions during his pontificate, and that Leo left the papacy deeply in debt.

Catholics can and should defend the doctrine of indulgences properly understood, but we should be honest that abuses surrounding indulgences caused real scandal. The Church herself later acted against financial abuses connected to indulgences; New Advent notes that St. Pius V canceled grants of indulgences involving fees or other financial transactions.

These stories are ugly. They should make Catholics uncomfortable. They make me uncomfortable.

But discomfort is not the same as disbelief.

The Catholic Defense Is Not to Defend the Indefensible

A Catholic should never say, “Those popes did nothing wrong.”

That is not apologetics. That is propaganda.

The better Catholic response is this: the sins of bad popes prove the reality of sin, not the falsehood of the Catholic faith.

Bad popes show us what happens when sacred office is treated as power instead of service. They show us what happens when politics, money, family ambition, lust, pride, and corruption enter the sanctuary. They show us why reform is necessary. They show us why the Church must always return to repentance.

The Catholic Church does not ask me to call evil good. In fact, Catholic morality requires the opposite. Sin is sin, even when committed by clergy. Scandal is scandal, even when caused by a pope.

I can defend the papacy without defending every pope.

I can defend apostolic succession without defending nepotism.

I can defend the Eucharist without defending corruption.

I can defend the Catholic faith without pretending every Catholic leader lived it well.

That distinction is everything.

Did Bad Popes Disprove Papal Infallibility?

No, because papal infallibility does not mean papal impeccability.

“Infallibility” means protection from error under specific conditions when the pope definitively teaches the universal Church on faith and morals. “Impeccability” would mean the inability to sin. Catholics do not believe popes are impeccable.

A pope can sin personally. A pope can govern badly. A pope can be a poor administrator. A pope can be politically reckless. A pope can appoint the wrong people. A pope can fail to discipline corruption. A pope can be arrogant, weak, worldly, or immoral.

None of that is the same thing as the Church solemnly binding all Catholics to heresy as part of the deposit of faith.

That is why the bad popes are a scandal, but not a disproof of Catholicism.

In some strange way, they may even point to something deeper. If the Church were merely a human institution, some of these men should have destroyed her. Yet the Mass survived. The sacraments survived. Scripture survived. The creeds survived. Apostolic succession survived. The saints kept coming. Reform kept happening. The Church was wounded, sometimes terribly, but not destroyed.

To me, that does not excuse the scandals. But it does suggest that the Church is held together by something greater than the personal virtue of her worst leaders.

Why Would God Allow Such Men to Become Pope?

This is the hardest question.

I do not know the full answer. No Catholic does.

But Scripture shows us again and again that God works through flawed people. David was chosen by God and still committed grave sins. Peter denied Christ. Judas was one of the Twelve. The apostles argued about greatness. Early Christian communities were filled with conflicts, scandals, and divisions.

God’s people have always needed purification.

That does not mean God approves of evil. It means God can remain faithful even when His people are not.

The bad popes are not proof that sin does not matter. They are proof that sin matters very much. Their sins wounded souls. Their scandals damaged the credibility of the Church. They gave ammunition to enemies of Catholicism and caused confusion among the faithful.

But the sins of men do not erase the promises of Christ.

Jesus did not promise that every shepherd would be holy. He promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against His Church.

A Catholic Can Be Loyal Without Being Blind

This is where I think Catholics need balance.

Some Catholics are so embarrassed by Church history that they begin to doubt everything. Others are so defensive that they refuse to admit anything bad happened. I do not think either approach is right.

A mature Catholic should be able to say:

Yes, there were bad popes.

Yes, some of them were very bad.

Yes, their sins caused scandal.

Yes, Catholics should be honest about that.

No, their sins do not disprove the Eucharist.

No, their sins do not erase apostolic succession.

No, their sins do not invalidate the sacraments.

No, their sins do not make Jesus Christ untrue.

No, I do not have to leave the Church because some men were unworthy of leading her.

That is not blind loyalty. That is faith with open eyes.

How Can I Be Catholic If So Many Popes Were Horrible?

I can be Catholic because my faith is not in the personal holiness of every pope.

My faith is in Jesus Christ.

I am Catholic because of the Eucharist. I am Catholic because of the sacraments. I am Catholic because of the apostolic faith handed down through the centuries. I am Catholic because I believe Christ gave real authority to His Church. I am Catholic because the Church, despite the sins of her members, still gives us Christ.

I remain Catholic not because every pope was worthy of the office, but because I believe Christ established a visible Church, a visible household, and a visible Kingdom — and because Christ, not the Pope, is the true King and final Head of that Church.

The bad popes humble me. They remind me not to idolize Church leaders. They remind me that Catholics must never confuse the Kingdom of God with clerical politics. They remind me that the Church must always be purified, always repentant, always returning to Christ.

They also remind me that I am a sinner too.

It is easy to look at the bad popes and feel disgust. Sometimes we should feel disgust. But I also have to ask myself: have I always lived the Gospel perfectly? Have I never been selfish, proud, lustful, cowardly, angry, dishonest, or worldly? The difference is that my sins are not recorded in history books. Their sins were.

That does not excuse them. It only reminds me why every Catholic, from the pope to the newest convert, needs mercy.

The Church Is Holy Because Christ Is Holy

The Catholic Church is not holy because every Catholic is holy.

The Church is holy because Christ is holy.

The Church is holy because her soul is the Holy Spirit. She is holy because her sacraments give grace. She is holy because her doctrine comes from Christ and the apostles. She is holy because saints continue to rise from her even in dark times.

But her members are sinners. Her clergy are sinners. Her bishops are sinners. Her popes are sinners.

Some popes became saints.

Some became scandals.

Christ remains Christ.

That is why I can stay Catholic. Not because every pope was good, but because Jesus is good. Not because every shepherd was faithful, but because the Good Shepherd is faithful. Not because the Church’s human history is spotless, but because grace is stronger than sin.

A bad pope can disgrace the Chair of Peter.

He cannot erase the promise of Christ.

A corrupt pope can wound the Church.

He cannot make the Eucharist cease to be Christ.

A sinful pope can cause scandal.

He cannot destroy the Gospel.

So yes, the bad popes were real. Some were horrible. Catholics should admit that honestly.

But I am still Catholic because my faith is not built on the perfection of men.

It is built on Jesus Christ, who chose Peter knowing Peter would fall, restored him after his denial, and still told him:

Feed my sheep.

A Short Catechism-Style Answer

Q: How can you be Catholic knowing some popes were so bad?

A: I am not Catholic because every pope was holy. I am Catholic because Christ is holy, and because I believe He founded a visible Church with real authority, real sacraments, and real apostolic succession.

Bad popes can disgrace the office of Peter, but they cannot destroy the promise of Christ.