Mardi Gras is Pagan

Mardi Gras and Carnival: A Catholic Perspective on Celebration, History, and Holiness

---

Mardi Gras—known as Carnivale in many Latin countries—will be celebrated on March 4th, 2025. For most people, both Catholic and non-Catholic, it’s a joyful, lively tradition marked by parades, music, and celebration. But not everyone sees it that way. Some view Mardi Gras as rooted in immorality, paganism, or even evil. So what’s the truth? And should Christians take part in it? This article explores the history, theology, and debates surrounding Mardi Gras to help answer that question.

---

Catholic Origins and Liturgical Context

Mardi Gras, or "Fat Tuesday," is the culmination of the Carnival season, a time of festivity before the penitential season of Lent. In Catholic tradition, Lent is a 40-day period of fasting, prayer, and almsgiving, modeled after Christ’s 40 days in the desert (Matthew 4:1–11). Mardi Gras is not a secular or pagan invention but has deep roots in the Christian liturgical calendar as a last joyful feast before the solemn discipline of Lent begins on Ash Wednesday.

The term "Carnival" is believed to originate from the Latin carne levare, meaning "to remove meat," symbolizing the upcoming Lenten abstinence from meat and rich foods. This final day of indulgence serves a purpose: to emphasize contrast, to fully appreciate the coming spiritual fast.

Historical Development Within the Church

As Christianity spread across Europe, it often baptized and adapted local customs into the liturgical life of the Church, not as compromise but as evangelization. Pope Gregory the Great, in the 6th century, instructed missionaries to preserve as much of indigenous culture as possible, redirecting it toward the worship of God. Thus, Carnival traditions—feasts, music, masquerades—were incorporated into Catholic societies as expressions of joy and community before Lent.

Cities like Venice and later colonial New Orleans developed elaborate Carnival customs rooted in Catholic cultures. These were not pagan revivals but incarnational in spirit: expressions of Catholic life that recognize the full range of human emotion and the rhythm of feasting and fasting.

Theological and Moral Framework

The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC 1809) teaches: “Temperance is the moral virtue that moderates the attraction of pleasures and provides balance in the use of created goods.” Carnival is legitimate as long as it is ordered toward the good, rooted in joy, and not disordered by sin.

Catholic theology acknowledges that celebration and joy are not sinful in themselves. Jesus attended feasts (John 2:1–11), and Ecclesiastes 3:4 reminds us there is "a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance."

But the Church strongly warns against turning Mardi Gras into an excuse for vice:

• Galatians 5:13: “Do not use your freedom as an opportunity for the flesh.”

• 1 Peter 2:16: “Live as people who are free, not using your freedom as a cover-up for evil.”

Pagan Concerns and Catholic Clarification

Some critics, particularly from Protestant backgrounds, accuse Mardi Gras of being a continuation of paganism or Babylonian mystery religions. This view often misunderstands the Church’s historical approach. Catholicism has long transformed what was once pagan into something sanctified.

The Church Fathers acknowledged this principle. St. Augustine famously said, “The devil is a monkey. He imitates the things of God.” Pagan practices that mirrored truth could be redeemed, redirected to God. Pope Benedict XVI emphasized this approach, urging Christians to transform culture rather than reject it wholesale.

The Danger of Excess

While Mardi Gras has Catholic roots, the Church does not endorse the sinful behavior sometimes associated with modern celebrations. The excesses—drunkenness, promiscuity, and revelry devoid of spiritual context—are not part of authentic Catholic Carnival. Rather, they reflect secularization and a loss of the season's true purpose.

St. Paul’s words apply clearly:

• Romans 13:13: “Let us behave decently, as in the daytime, not in orgies and drunkenness, not in sexual immorality and debauchery.”

Where Mardi Gras becomes an occasion for mortal sin, it is no longer Catholic in spirit. Catholics are called to celebrate rightly, with joy rooted in gratitude, not license.

Should Catholics Celebrate Mardi Gras?

Yes—if it is celebrated in the proper Catholic spirit.

Catholicism embraces the body and the senses as good, created by God. Celebration is part of being human. But every celebration must be ordered toward virtue. Mardi Gras is not evil—it is human, cultural, and spiritual when understood correctly. As Pope Francis said, “A Christian is joyful. Even in pain and persecution, the Christian sings. Joy is the sign of the presence of God.”

Guidelines for Catholic Participation:

• Intention: Celebrate with the goal of honoring God and building community.

• Moderation: Avoid gluttony, drunkenness, and scandal.

• Preparation: Let Mardi Gras remind you that Lent is coming—make a plan for penance and prayer.

Conclusion

Mardi Gras is not a mistake or a pagan leftover—it is a Catholic cultural expression of joy before penance. It reflects the Church’s understanding of human nature: we are not angels, but embodied souls who need seasons of both feasting and fasting. Like all good things, Carnival must be ordered by virtue. Celebrated rightly, Mardi Gras becomes a prelude to spiritual renewal. Celebrated wrongly, it becomes a parody of its purpose.

The Church does not reject culture; it redeems it. And Mardi Gras, in its authentic form, is one more way Catholics live the rhythm of grace in time.